Meditate

Kind of meditation

Christian contemplative prayer: lectio divina and centering prayer

Contemplative prayer is a form of Christian prayer that aims less at saying words than at being silent before God. It has a history of more than sixteen hundred years, with practices such as *lectio divina* and, since the twentieth century, centering prayer. It is prayer within a faith, not a meditation technique borrowed from elsewhere, and it is described that way here.

What it is

It is a set of Christian practices in which a person, in silence, makes themselves available to the presence of God. For those who practice them, they are not first of all an exercise for calming the mind, though calm may come, but a relationship: prayer.

A 1989 document of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith defines Christian prayer as "a personal, intimate and profound dialogue between man and God," a meeting between God's infinite freedom and the finite freedom of the person. That phrase helps explain what is being done, and what is not.

Where and when it began

The earliest clear writings on contemplative prayer are by John Cassian, in the fourth century, who learned from the so-called Desert Fathers. From the monastic world also comes lectio divina ("divine reading"): its roots reach back to Origen in the third century, and Benedict of Nursia established it in monastic life in the sixth century, when chapter 48 of his Rule set times for it.

In the twelfth century, Guigo II, a Carthusian prior, described it in an orderly way in The Ladder of Monks, with four moments: lectio (reading a passage of Scripture), meditatio (reflecting on its meaning), oratio (answering in prayer) and contemplatio (a quiet, loving attentiveness to God). In the Eastern Orthodox tradition, hesychasm uses the Jesus Prayer, which is repeated many times; it is a different practice from lectio divina, which moves through different passages and is not essentially repetitive.

How it is traditionally practiced

Lectio divina is read slowly, sometimes aloud, pausing on whatever strikes you. The Second Vatican Council's document on revelation, Dei Verbum (1965), emphasized it, and in 2005 Benedict XVI recalled "the ancient tradition of Lectio Divina" and said it would bring the Church "a new spiritual springtime." There are Protestant and Anglican versions too.

Centering prayer is credited to Trappist monks of St. Joseph's Abbey in Spencer, Massachusetts: William Meninger, Basil Pennington and Thomas Keating, who was abbot of that monastery in the 1960s and 1970s. The name comes from Thomas Merton, who described contemplative prayer as "centered entirely on the presence of God." It draws on The Cloud of Unknowing and on Teresa of Avila and John of the Cross.

Pennington summarized it in four steps: sit comfortably, choose a sacred word, let it represent your intention to be present to God, and return to it gently whenever thoughts arise. For those who practice it, the word is not a tool for quieting the mind but a gesture of consent to God's presence. Keating spoke of letting go of every kind of thought, even devout ones.

How it reached the present

Keating wanted to offer Christian contemplation to younger people drawn to Eastern traditions. Today centering prayer is shared through a network of groups, among them Contemplative Outreach, which publishes guidelines for the practice.

It has not been free of debate inside the Catholic Church. In 1989 the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, headed by Cardinal Ratzinger, issued the letter Orationis formas on some aspects of Christian meditation. It warns against attempts to fuse Christian meditation with what is not Christian, and also says that methods from other religions should not be rejected out of hand just because they are not Christian, and that useful elements may be adopted if reformulated according to the aim of Christian prayer. Keating said the letter did not apply directly to centering prayer, and the letter does not name it. Critics hold that it conflicts with Catholic teaching and its defenders deny this. It is an open debate, and this page does not settle it.

What studies say

Almost all meditation research concerns other practices, mainly mindfulness programs, and it cannot be carried over to prayer. No solid study of contemplative prayer could be confirmed from a primary source, so none is cited here and no effect is claimed. If prayer accompanies you, it is because of what it means in your faith.

How it differs from its neighbors

From Buddhist meditation: Buddhist mindfulness and concentration are not prayer and are not addressed to God. From mantra practice: in centering prayer, those who practice it describe the sacred word as the expression of an intention, not as a sound of power. From Christian "meditation": in that tradition the term can mean structured reflection on a passage or a scene, like the second moment of lectio divina.

This site offers no prayer practices. If you want a silent meditation with one point of support, the nearest in spirit is the one on the breath.

Common confusions

Thinking that centering prayer is a "Christian Transcendental Meditation": it developed independently, though practitioners often compare the two. Thinking that lectio divina is Bible study for information: its stated purpose is prayerful reading. And thinking it is a neutral technique anyone can lift out of context: for those who practice it, it is prayer, and it is described here with that respect.

Common questions

What is contemplative prayer?

A form of Christian prayer in silence that seeks to be before God rather than to say words. It includes practices such as lectio divina and centering prayer.

What is lectio divina?

A monastic practice of reading Scripture in four moments: reading, reflecting, praying and contemplating. Guigo II, a twelfth-century Carthusian prior, described it in an orderly way.

Who created centering prayer?

It was developed in the twentieth century at the Trappist St. Joseph's Abbey in Spencer, Massachusetts, by William Meninger, Basil Pennington and Thomas Keating. It rests on a long Christian tradition.

Is it the same as meditating?

Not exactly. It is prayer within a faith, with a different purpose from mindfulness or concentration. Though it shares silence and the return to a point of support with them, it is not a borrowed technique.

Sources

To practice something similar here