Meditate

Kind of meditation

MBSR: the Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction program

MBSR stands for Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction. It is not a way of meditating but a program: an eight-week group course created by Jon Kabat-Zinn at the University of Massachusetts in 1979. It is the most studied mindfulness program, and others grew out of it.

What it is

It is a structured program with a fixed format, not a tradition. It is classed as an educational intervention rather than psychotherapy. It brings together several practices: mindfulness meditation, the body scan and simple yoga postures, plus group conversation about applying what you practice to daily life.

That is why, when someone says "MBSR works" or "MBSR doesn't work," they are talking about the whole: the practices, the group, the teacher and the home assignments. An effect seen in the program cannot be credited to any single part of it.

Where and when it began

Jon Kabat-Zinn founded the Stress Reduction Clinic at the University of Massachusetts Medical Center in 1979. His first scientific paper on the program is from 1982, in General Hospital Psychiatry: it described a ten-week program for 51 adults with chronic pain who had not improved with usual medical care. It was a study with no comparison group; at ten weeks, 65 percent had a reduction of at least a third in their pain rating score, and mood also improved. The author himself noted the limits of that design.

The program draws on several sources, and it presents itself as secular. According to the reference article, it takes elements from Zen, hatha yoga, the samatha-vipassanā tradition and Advaita Vedanta. Its key book is Full Catastrophe Living (1990, reissued in 2013).

How it is organized

There are eight weekly group sessions of about two and a half to three hours, preceded by an orientation session. Between weeks six and seven comes an all-day retreat of six to seven and a half hours, often in silence. Daily home practice of 45 to 60 minutes, six days a week, is expected, usually with guided audio.

The course includes exploring habits of thinking, feeling and acting. Kabat-Zinn defines mindfulness as "moment-to-moment, non-judgmental awareness." This page is not the program and does not replace it, and this site does not offer it, though its guided body scan and breath meditations start from practices the program uses.

What it gave rise to

The best-known offshoot is mindfulness-based cognitive therapy, MBCT. It was developed by combining MBSR with elements of cognitive therapy, and the classic description is by Segal, Williams and Teasdale (2002). It is also an eight-week program, with weekly sessions of about two hours and an all-day class after the fifth week, and it is designed to prevent relapse in people with recurrent depression.

There are many other courses with similar names. When you see "mindfulness-based," it is worth asking what structure it has, how many weeks it runs and who teaches it.

What studies say

MBSR underlies much of the research on mindfulness. According to the reference article, a 2014 review found moderate evidence of improvement in anxiety, depression and pain, and low evidence for stress, mood and sleep. A 2013 meta-analysis found MBSR no more effective than cognitive behavioral therapy, and a 2021 Cochrane review could not confirm its usefulness for medical students and junior doctors, because of few studies and risk of bias.

The US National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) summarizes that mindfulness-based approaches worked as well as evidence-based therapies for anxiety and depression, in a 2018 analysis. A 2021 analysis found that the few studies with follow-up beyond two months showed no long-term effects. For MBSR specifically, a 2020 review associated it with a reduction in blood pressure, and a 2020 report from the agency AHRQ linked it to short-term improvement in low-back pain but not fibromyalgia pain.

What they do not show: that it is superior to other treatments, or that its effects last. NCCIH also warns that much of the research has been preliminary or not rigorous.

How it differs from its neighbors

From mindfulness: mindfulness is a quality and a practice; MBSR is a course that teaches it. From psychotherapy: MBSR is educational, while MBCT does incorporate elements of therapy. From meditation retreats: here there is a single retreat day inside a course, not a stretch of intensive practice.

Confusions and care

Thinking MBSR is "mindfulness" in general, or equal to any meditation course. Thinking it ends stress: it is a learning program, not a treatment. NCCIH advises against using meditation or mindfulness to replace or delay conventional health care, and suggests asking about the instructor's training.

The practice can bring up difficult emotions. You can stop whenever you like, and with trauma or strong distress it is wise to talk with a mental health professional first.

Common questions

What is MBSR?

An eight-week group program created by Jon Kabat-Zinn at the University of Massachusetts in 1979. It combines mindfulness meditation, the body scan, simple yoga postures and conversation.

How long is an MBSR course?

Eight weekly sessions of about two and a half to three hours, an orientation session, an all-day retreat and daily home practice of about 45 to 60 minutes.

What is the difference between MBSR and MBCT?

MBCT grew out of MBSR by adding elements of cognitive therapy, and it was designed to prevent relapse in recurrent depression. MBSR is a more general educational program.

Is MBSR scientifically proven?

There is moderate evidence of improvement in anxiety, depression and pain, with small effects. It was not shown to beat other treatments, and there is little data on long-term effects.

Sources

To practice something similar here