Meditate

Kind of meditation

Mantra meditation: the repeated word, from the Vedas to today

Mantra meditation means repeating a word, a syllable or a phrase, aloud, in a whisper or silently, and returning to it each time the mind wanders. It is one of the oldest and most widespread practices in the world, rooted in Vedic India, and it lives inside many religious traditions as well as in secular form.

What a mantra is

The word comes from Sanskrit mantra, which joins man- ("mind") and -tra (an instrument suffix): something like a "tool of thought." In the traditions where it began, a mantra is a sound, syllable, word or formula with sacred power.

In everyday English, "mantra" now means any phrase you repeat to keep yourself going, and that is something else. In meditation, a mantra is the single object of attention. You do not analyze it. You repeat it and come back to it.

Where and when it began

The earliest mentions of mantras are in the Vedas of ancient India and in the Avesta of ancient Iran. Because Sanskrit mantra and Avestan mąθra go back to one Proto-Indo-Iranian form, the idea is often placed around 2000 BCE, and mantra use in India generally before 1000 BCE.

Scholars disagree about what a mantra is. Frits Staal compared mantras to bird song: ordered sound with no linguistic meaning. Harvey Alper argues from a linguistic view. Even in antiquity, the Vedic thinker Kautsa held that mantras work phonetically and syntactically, not semantically.

How it is traditionally practiced

The meditative repetition of a mantra is called japa. It is often done with a mala, a string of beads, most commonly 108, though 5, 10, 28 and 1008 also appear. Each bead marks one repetition.

Mantras live in Hinduism (Om is the seed syllable, bīja, regarded as the first sound), in Jainism, in Sikhism and in Buddhism, where Om mani padme hum is among the best known. In Japan, the Shingon school takes its name from the Chinese 真言 (zhēnyán), "true words." Rules about who teaches a mantra, to whom and how differ from one tradition to the next, and this page does not describe them.

This is not a practice offered here: the site has no mantra meditations. The nearest in spirit are the ones that hold a single object, such as counting or following the breath.

How it reached the present

In the twentieth century the mantra stepped out of religious settings. The best-known case is Transcendental Meditation, a technique Maharishi Mahesh Yogi began teaching publicly in India in 1955; he said he learned it from his teacher, Brahmananda Saraswati. "Transcendental Meditation" is a registered name: Maharishi Foundation, Ltd. trademarked it in 1984.

As it is usually described, you silently repeat a mantra assigned to you for 15 to 20 minutes, twice a day, sitting with your eyes closed, and you learn it in a multi-step course whose fees vary by country. That is a statement of fact, not a recommendation. In 1977 a US district court ruled that a Transcendental Meditation curriculum in some New Jersey schools was religious and violated the First Amendment; the court of appeals upheld it (Malnak v. Yogi, 1979).

What studies say

There is no body of studies on "mantras" in general. The most cited work concerns Transcendental Meditation and blood pressure. In 2013, an American Heart Association scientific statement (Brook and colleagues, Hypertension 61) reviewed approaches that use neither drugs nor diet. It gave Transcendental Meditation a Class IIB recommendation, evidence level B, and other meditation techniques Class III, level C, meaning no demonstrated benefit. For behavioral therapies as a group it found "modest, mixed, or no consistent" evidence. It concluded that people with blood pressure above 120/80 mm Hg might reasonably consider these approaches as add-ons, not as replacements.

Beyond that, reviews tend to complain of uneven quality. When you read a study of Transcendental Meditation, it helps to check who ran it and what it was compared with. For its part, the US National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) describes mantra as "a repeated word or phrase" and notes that much meditation research has been preliminary or not rigorous.

How it differs from its neighbors

From breath practices: a mantra is an object you choose and produce yourself, while the breath is already there. From mindfulness: mindfulness observes whatever arises, while mantra repeats one object. From affirmations: a mantra is not meant to convince you of anything, and it may carry no meaning for the person using it.

Repeating a word silently is not unique to Transcendental Meditation either: it appears in japa, in Buddhist practices and in Christian centering prayer, and each has its own meaning.

Common questions

What is a mantra and what is it for?

It is a sound, word or phrase repeated as the object of attention. In the traditions where it began it carries sacred value; in secular practice it works as a point to return to when the mind scatters.

What is a mala and why does it have 108 beads?

It is a string of beads for counting repetitions. 108 is the most common number, though 5, 10, 28 and 1008 also exist. The reason for 108 depends on the tradition, and no single explanation is claimed here.

Is Transcendental Meditation the same as mantra meditation?

No. It is a registered name for one specific technique and course, created by Maharishi Mahesh Yogi. Mantra meditation is a much wider family of practices.

Does a mantra need to have a meaning?

Scholars disagree. Some say the value lies in the sound, others that the meaning matters. Each tradition settles it in its own way.

Sources

To practice something similar here