Getting ready
- Sit on a chair, a cushion or the edge of your bed, with your back upright but not tense. If sitting is not possible for you, lie on your back.
- Rest your hands on your legs or one inside the other. The numbers are said silently, without moving your lips or fingers.
- Close your eyes or lower your gaze to the floor without fixing it on anything.
- If you need to shift, do it slowly and start counting again from one. Moving does not spoil the practice.
- A wooden knock sounds at the end. Stay for a few seconds before you get up.
The full script
This is what you will hear. Between one line and the next there are silences; they are part of the practice.
Sit in a way you can keep for a while, upright but not tense. Close your eyes if you like. Or lower your gaze to the floor, without fixing it. Let your hands rest where they are at ease. Feel where your body meets the chair, the cushion or the floor. Let the breath go on by itself. Just notice it coming in and going out. Notice above all the end of each out-breath, when the air has finished leaving. In this practice you count out-breaths, from one to ten. At the end of the first out-breath, silently say one. At the end of the next, two. When you reach ten, start again at one. If you lose count, or go past ten, start again at one. It happens to everyone. Begin when you like. One, on the next out-breath. Keep the number soft, almost a whisper inside. The breath keeps its own pace.
You don't need to reach ten. Counting just shows you where your attention is.
When you notice you were thinking of something else, nothing went wrong. Minds do that. Back to one.
Keep counting on your own. One, two, three, one out-breath at a time.
If anything becomes too much, open your eyes or move. You can stop whenever you want. If the number starts pushing the breath, let the air set the pace. The number just follows.
Between one number and the next, stay with the feeling of the air.
Keep going, one to ten, and again from one.
If you got lost, no scolding. One.
Now stop counting. The breath goes on, without numbers. Let your attention open to the whole body and the sounds around you. Slowly move your hands and feet. When you are ready, open your eyes. That is all. You can count again any time today, even to ten just once.
What it is
This is a focused-attention practice with one aid: a number. Each time the air finishes going out, you count one more, from one to ten, and then start over. If at some point you realize you lost count, or that you were up to fourteen, you simply go back to one.
The count is not a goal. It helps you notice sooner that your mind has wandered: a missing number tips you off. That sets it apart from breath meditation, where you just keep the air company, and from paced breathing exercises, where you count to lengthen or hold the breath. Here the air goes as it likes and the number comes after.
Where it comes from
The early discourse on breathing, the Ānāpānasati Sutta, teaches knowing each in-breath and each out-breath, but it says nothing about counting. Counting shows up in later manuals. The Visuddhimagga, written by Buddhaghosa in the fifth century, describes counting as the first stage of attention to the breath, set aside once attention can follow the air without numbers. Vasubandhu's Abhidharmakośa also teaches counting breaths up to ten.
In Zen the practice is called sūsokukan in Japanese, contemplation by counting breaths. In the Rinzai school the usual method is to count each exhalation from one to ten and go back to one when the count is lost. Other schools count the in-breath as one and the out-breath as two. Dōgen, who founded Sōtō Zen in Japan, saw it as a holdover from what he called Hinayana, the "lesser vehicle", while Keizan, another teacher of the same school, recommended it.
Many Zen centers still teach it as the first instruction. One puts it this way: when you reach ten, start over with one, and if you lose track, do the same. Whether you ever reach ten, it adds, is not important.
What people use it for
Many people reach for it on days when the mind is very busy and staying with the bare breath feels hard. The number gives you something concrete to do, and going back to one shows you, without judgment, when you drifted.
Beginners use it because the whole instruction fits in one sentence. Longtime meditators use it too, as a way to settle attention at the start of a session before moving on to another practice.
What studies say
Breath counting has been studied mostly as a measure, not as a treatment. In 2014 Levinson and colleagues published four studies in Frontiers in Psychology, with more than 400 participants in all, in which people counted breaths from one to nine. Counting more accurately went along with more awareness of what one's own mind was doing and less mind-wandering. People with years of meditation counted more accurately than beginners.
In the last of those studies, four weeks of online counting practice raised people's self-reported mindfulness and reduced mind-wandering compared with two control groups. The groups were small, 20 to 29 people, and the gain in counting accuracy fell short of clear. These are findings about attention, not about health.
For health, what exists are studies of full mindfulness programs. A 2014 review in JAMA Internal Medicine of 47 trials found moderate evidence of improvement in anxiety, depression and pain, and insufficient evidence about attention. None of those trials studied breath counting on its own.
What you may notice
The most common experience at first is never getting past three or four. That is not a bad sign: it is the first time you see in numbers how much the mind moves. Going back to one is the practice, not a penalty.
Sometimes the opposite happens: the count runs on by itself, like a machine, while you think about something else. If you reach ten without having felt a single breath, start over and put your attention on the air between one number and the next.
Sleepiness, restlessness and boredom are normal too. For sleepiness, open your eyes and straighten your back. If counting makes you tense or makes you force the breath, drop the numbers and stay with the air alone. If a strong emotion comes up, you can open your eyes, move or stop.
Which length to choose
All three lengths use the same words; what changes is the silence. In five minutes the voice reminds you of the count often. In ten there are long stretches of counting on your own. In fifteen the voice comes in only a few times and you count in silence most of the time.
To begin, five minutes on most days tends to work better than fifteen once in a while. When counting gets easy, try dropping the numbers at the end and staying a while with the air alone.
Common mistakes
- Breathing to the rhythm of the numbers. The air comes first; the number follows.
- Trying to reach ten. A broken count is exactly what lets you see you drifted.
- Counting on autopilot. If you are counting without feeling the air, start again at one.
- Getting annoyed every time you go back to one. Going back is the practice.
- Counting past ten. When you reach ten, return to one.
Keep in mind
- If paying attention to your breath makes you feel short of air or more anxious, drop the count and rest your attention on your hands, your feet or sounds.
- Meditation can stir up difficult feelings. You can open your eyes, move or stop at any time.
- If you live with trauma or strong emotional distress, talk to a mental health professional first.
Common questions
Do I count in-breaths or out-breaths?
In this meditation you count out-breaths, at the end of each exhalation, as in the most common Rinzai Zen method. Some schools count the in-breath as one and the out-breath as two. Both work; what matters is choosing one and not switching midway.
Why only up to ten?
It is the number the traditional manuals set and the one Zen centers still teach. It gives you a short stretch that is easy to keep track of, with a clear end before you start over. If ten feels long, that is fine: go back to one whenever you get lost.
What if I never reach ten?
Nothing changes. That is what happens to almost everyone at first. Each time you go back to one, you are practicing; the count is not a test.
Is counting breaths the same as box breathing?
No. In box breathing and other paced exercises you count in order to lengthen or hold the breath on purpose. Here you do not change the breath: the air goes out when it goes out, and the number only marks that you noticed.
Do I always have to count?
No. The tradition teaches it as a support, especially for beginners. Once attention settles, you can drop the numbers and simply stay with the air, as you do at the end of this meditation.
Sources
- Gaṇanā, breath counting in Buddhism and Zen, with its scholarly references
- Buddhaghosa, Visuddhimagga VIII, the counting method, Pali text with Ñāṇamoli's translation
- Beginner's Mind Zen Center, How to do zazen, breath counting instructions
- Levinson et al. (2014), A mind you can count on: validating breath counting as a behavioral measure of mindfulness, Frontiers in Psychology 5
- Goyal et al. (2014), Meditation programs for psychological stress and well-being, JAMA Internal Medicine 174(3)