Meditate

Attention

Noting meditation

You follow the belly rising and falling, and when something pulls you away you give it one silent word, thinking, hearing, feeling, and come back. It suits days when the mind will not stop, and it takes ten, fifteen or twenty minutes.

10 min15 min20 min

Getting ready

  1. Sit on a chair, a cushion or the edge of your bed, with your back long but not stiff. If sitting is not possible for you, lie on your back.
  2. Rest your hands on your legs or one on top of the other. If the belly is hard to feel, rest a hand on it for the first few minutes.
  3. Close your eyes or let your gaze rest low on the floor.
  4. The words are said silently, in a quiet inner voice, without moving your lips.
  5. If you need to move, note the urge, move slowly and come back. A wooden knock sounds at the end; stay for a few seconds before you get up.

The full script

This is what you will hear. Between one line and the next there are silences; they are part of the practice.

Sit in a way you can keep without effort, with your back long. Close your eyes if you like. Or let your gaze rest low on the floor. Let your hands rest. Notice the weight of your body. Bring your attention to your belly. Notice how it moves as you breathe, changing nothing. When the belly rises, you can silently say rising. When it falls, falling. The word is soft, almost a whisper. What matters is the feeling, not the word. Rising. Falling. Stay with it for a while, at your own pace.

Sooner or later, something will pull you away. A thought, a sound, an itch. When you notice, give it one word. If you were thinking, silently say thinking. If you hear something, hearing. If something aches or itches, feeling. Once you have named it, come back to the belly. Rising. Falling.

You don't need the exact word. Thinking, hearing or feeling will do.

The word is not for fighting what shows up. It only says you saw it.

Keep going on your own. The belly, and one word for whatever pulls you away.

If a memory or a plan shows up, you can say remembering or planning. Or just thinking.

If an emotion shows up, you can name it. Sadness, anger, worry. In the same soft tone.

If you catch yourself judging how you are doing, that has a word too. Judging.

A wandering mind is not a mistake. That is what minds do. Naming it is already coming back.

If anything becomes too much, open your eyes or move. You can stop whenever you want. If the words start to get in the way, drop them for a while. Just noticing is enough.

Go on by yourself. Rising, falling, and a word when you need one.

If sleepiness comes, name that too. Sleepy. And straighten your back a little.

If nothing pulls you away, stay with the belly. Rising. Falling.

Notice the moment something starts to appear, before it sweeps you off.

If you went far away, no scolding. Thinking. And come back.

Keep going, in silence. The voice will come back in a while.

Now stop naming. Let the words go. Notice a few more breaths, without words. Notice your whole body and the sounds around you. Slowly move your hands and feet. When you are ready, open your eyes. That is all. A soft word stays within reach for the rest of the day.

What it is

This is a mental noting practice. You have an anchor, the movement of the belly as you breathe, and when something pulls you away you give it a silent word: thinking, hearing, feeling. Then you return to the belly. The word is soft and short; it does not describe or explain, it only acknowledges what happened.

It differs from breath meditation in that whatever distracts you is not simply set aside: it gets named. And it differs from open awareness in that there is an object to come back to and a label for each thing that shows up. Naming helps you see when a thought started to carry you off, and keeps you from mistaking yourself for it.

Where it comes from

Noting is the hallmark of the method taught by Mahasi Sayadaw, a Burmese monk born near Shwebo in 1904 who died in 1982. In his instructions, translated into English by U Pe Thin in 1957, you watch the abdomen and note rising as it rises and falling as it falls. When a thought arises you note thinking, thinking; when you hear something, hearing, hearing. Then you return to the abdomen.

His text is called Satipaṭṭhāna Vipassanā, after the Satipaṭṭhāna Sutta, the Buddhist discourse on the foundations of mindfulness, which asks you to know the body, feelings and states of mind as they present themselves. Vipassanā is a Pali word usually translated as clear seeing or insight.

Mahasi's method spread from Burma to other parts of Asia and then to the West, carried by teachers trained in that line. The version on this page is secular and gentler: it uses a single word instead of repeating it, and it is not part of a retreat or a religious path.

What people use it for

Many people use it on days when the mind will not stop. Naming a thought turns it into something that happened, rather than something you are inside of. Some people say that gives them a little distance.

It also helps people who drift for long stretches without noticing: the word marks the moment you caught it. And it is a way to learn your own mind's habits, because after a few sessions you see which words come up most.

What studies say

There are no clinical trials of mental noting on its own. What has been studied are mindfulness programs that combine several practices, some of them inspired by the Burmese vipassanā movement.

A review published in 2014 in JAMA Internal Medicine pooled 47 trials with 3,515 participants and found moderate evidence of improvement in anxiety, depression and pain for mindfulness programs, and low evidence for stress and quality of life. It did not find them better than other active treatments. Those data cannot tell you what naming thoughts adds.

What you may notice

At first it can feel as if all you do is name: thinking, thinking, hearing, thinking. That is normal. Over time the stretches with the belly usually get longer, though not always.

Sometimes the word turns harsh, like a scolding. If that happens, soften it until it is almost a whisper. If the words feel like too much, drop them for a while and simply notice.

Sleepiness, restlessness or strong emotions may come up. Sleepiness and restlessness can be named too. If an emotion grows too big, you do not need to keep naming: open your eyes, move or stop.

Which length to choose

All three lengths say the same words; what grows is the silence. In ten minutes the voice reminds you of the words often. In fifteen there are long stretches of noting on your own. In twenty almost the whole practice is yours.

To begin, ten minutes is enough. When noting starts to feel natural, try fifteen or twenty, or use a single word at other moments of the day, when you notice a worry has carried you off.

Common mistakes

  • Hunting for the perfect word. Thinking, hearing and feeling cover almost everything.
  • Using the word to push away what shows up. Naming is acknowledging, not removing.
  • Saying the words harshly. Tone matters: soft, almost a whisper.
  • Naming nonstop and forgetting the belly. After the word, come back.
  • Turning the session into an inventory. You do not need to name everything, only what pulls you away.

Keep in mind

  • If naming an emotion makes it grow, drop the words, open your eyes or move. You can stop whenever you want.
  • Meditation can stir up difficult feelings. Stopping is not the practice failing.
  • If you live with trauma or strong emotional distress, talk to a mental health professional first.

Common questions

What is noting in meditation?

It means giving a short silent word to whatever shows up while you meditate: thinking, hearing, feeling. It comes from the Burmese *vipassanā* method taught by Mahasi Sayadaw. It helps you notice sooner that you drifted, and come back.

What words can I use?

The simplest: thinking, hearing, feeling. If you want more detail, remembering, planning or judging, or the name of an emotion. You do not have to get it right; any word that acknowledges what happened will do.

Do I have to say the word twice?

In Mahasi Sayadaw's instructions the note is repeated, thinking, thinking. In this version you say it once, to keep it light. Try both and keep whichever helps you come back.

Doesn't naming thoughts make them stronger?

Sometimes, especially if the word sounds like a scolding or the emotion is intense. That is why the tone is soft and brief. If naming hooks you further, drop the words and simply notice.

Sources