Meditate

Practical guide · 3 min read

When meditation stirs up difficult feelings

When you sit in silence, feelings can come up that you did not notice during the day: sadness, fear, anger, a memory. Sometimes they pass on their own; sometimes they weigh on you. Research documents that meditation can have unwanted effects. Here is what has been found, what to do in the moment, when to stop and when to talk to a mental health professional.

What people report

Lindahl and colleagues (2017, PLoS ONE) interviewed Western meditators and experts from Theravāda, Zen and Tibetan traditions. They described 59 meditation-related experiences, grouped in seven areas: cognitive, perceptual, affective, bodily, motivational, sense of self and social. The experiences ranged from very positive to very negative, and the distress from minimal and passing to severe and lasting. The same experience was lived very differently by different people.

In other words, a difficult feeling coming up is not a problem in itself, and at the same time some people do go through serious difficulties. Both are documented.

How common it is

Farias and colleagues (2020, Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica) reviewed 83 studies with 6,703 adults who meditated. In 55 of them (65 percent), at least one adverse event was reported. The pooled prevalence was 8.3 percent, but it differed a lot by design: 3.7 percent in experimental studies and 33.2 percent in observational ones. Among studies that reported events, the most common were anxiety (33 percent), depression (27 percent) and cognitive disturbances (25 percent). The authors conclude they are not rare and can occur in people with no history of mental health problems.

The gap between 3.7 and 33.2 percent shows how much the number depends on how people are asked. The U.S. NCCIH sums it up this way: meditation is usually considered low risk, but harm has been studied little. It cites that review and its figure of about 8 percent, similar to psychological therapies.

Baer and colleagues (2019, Clinical Psychology Review) note that when trials of mindfulness-based programs report adverse events, they appear in 0 to 10.6 percent of people, at rates similar to comparison groups, but few studies record them and averages can hide the people who get worse. None of this shows that meditation causes the distress, or that it does not.

What to do in the moment

  • Open your eyes and look around the room: name three things you see.
  • Put your feet on the floor and feel your weight on the chair or cushion.
  • Name what is happening without analyzing it: "sadness," "fear," "a memory." Naming can give it a little room.
  • Move your attention to something outside you and neutral: sounds, your hands, walking slowly.
  • Move, drink some water, stretch.
  • End the session if it does not settle. Stopping is a valid decision, not a failure.
  • Talk to someone you trust, or write down what happened, when you are done.

When to stop, and how to go slower

Stop the session if the feeling grows instead of passing, if you feel overwhelmed, if panic, a sense of unreality or very vivid memories appear, or if you feel worse after several days. You are not required to wait for it to "pass."

To go slower, shorten your sessions, practice with your eyes open, choose meditations that put attention outside, like sounds, and set aside for a while the ones that stir things up. The guided meditations on this site remind you that you can open your eyes or stop whenever you like. Writing in the diary how you feel before and after helps you see what works for you.

When to talk to a professional

Talk to a mental health professional if these feelings keep returning, if you have trouble sleeping or functioning during the day, or if you are thinking about hurting yourself. If you live with trauma or strong emotional distress, it is wise to talk to a professional before you start or before you continue. If you are in crisis, seek emergency help or a support line in your country.

NCCIH advises against using meditation to replace health care or to delay seeing a provider, and suggests asking about the training and experience of whoever teaches. If you already have treatment, tell your team that you meditate.

Meditation is a practice, not a treatment. That it is hard does not mean you are doing it wrong, and it does not mean you have to push through.

Common questions

Is it normal to cry or feel sad while meditating?

Yes, many people report it. It can happen and not be a problem. If it weighs on you, lasts after the session or keeps coming back, you can stop and talk to a mental health professional.

Can meditation make anxiety or depression worse?

Studies document anxiety and depression as unwanted effects in a share of people who meditate. It is not well known how often, or in whom. If you notice you are getting worse, stop and get advice.

What do I do if a very strong memory comes up?

Open your eyes, put your feet on the floor and look around the room. If it is a memory of something traumatic or very painful, stop the session and talk to a professional. You do not have to keep meditating with it.

Should I keep meditating if I feel worse?

You do not have to push. Take a break, try short sessions with your attention outside, and talk to a mental health professional if it lasts.

Is meditation safe?

It is usually considered low risk, but it is not free of unwanted effects, and harm has been studied little. It is reasonable to pay attention to how you feel and stop when you need to.

Sources

To practice

Keep reading