What looks like a mistake and isn't
Getting distracted is not a mistake. The practice is the moment you notice you drifted and come back, so a session full of thoughts has many returns, and each one counts. Neither are sleepiness, boredom or restlessness: they are normal in the first weeks.
The real mistakes are different, and they have more to do with attitude and planning than with technique.
Six common mistakes
- Trying to blank your mind. Trying to empty it tends to bring more thoughts, because you are watching for them. The instruction is to attend to something, like the breath or sounds, and come back when you drift.
- Grading the session. "That went badly" or "that went well" turns practice into an exam. A calm session and a restless one are two sessions; neither is the good one.
- Starting too long. Thirty minutes on day one often ends in a week of quitting. Three to five minutes you repeat are worth more.
- Pushing through pain. Ignoring a strong ache isn't discipline. Change posture, use a chair, and if the pain is sharp, stop.
- Expecting fast results. Meditation isn't a switch. Below you'll see what studies show, which is modest.
- Quitting after a missed day. One day off doesn't erase the earlier ones. Pick it up the next day, with no debt.
What to expect, according to research
A 2014 review in JAMA Internal Medicine (Goyal and colleagues) pooled 47 trials with 3,515 participants. It found moderate evidence of improvement in anxiety, depression and pain with mindfulness programs, and low evidence for stress and quality of life. For attention and sleep, it found low evidence of no effect, or insufficient evidence of any effect. And it did not find them better than other active treatments.
These are programs of several weeks, with a teacher and nearly daily practice, not a first week. That is where the expecting-fast mistake comes from: what was measured is slow and modest. Meditation is a practice, not a treatment, and doesn't replace health care.
When continuing is not the answer
The seventh mistake, perhaps the most serious, is pushing on when something is hurting you. The U.S. National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) says these practices are generally considered low-risk, but that few studies have looked at harmful effects. In a 2020 review it cites, about 8 percent of participants had a negative effect; the most common were anxiety and depression.
Lindahl and colleagues (2017, PLOS ONE) described, with practitioners from Buddhist traditions, difficult experiences ranging from mild and passing to severe and lasting. If strong anguish or hard memories come up when you meditate, or you feel worse week after week, stop. Talk to a mental health professional, especially if you live with trauma or strong emotional distress.
Common questions
How do I know if I'm meditating correctly?
If you attend to something, drift and come back, you are practicing. There is no right sensation to reach.
Is it a mistake to meditate lying down?
No. It is a valid posture, though sleep comes more easily. If you want to stay awake, try sitting.
Do I have to meditate every day?
No. Most days, for a stretch you can keep up, is a good starting point. One missed day ruins nothing.
Should I keep meditating if it makes me feel bad?
No. If strong anguish comes up or you feel worse, you can stop. Talk to a mental health professional, especially with trauma or strong emotional distress.
Sources
- Goyal et al. (2014), Meditation programs for psychological stress and well-being, JAMA Internal Medicine 174(3)
- NCCIH, U.S. National Institutes of Health: Meditation and Mindfulness, What You Need To Know
- Lindahl et al. (2017), The varieties of contemplative experience: A mixed-methods study of meditation-related challenges in Western Buddhists, PLOS ONE 12(5)