Meditate

Background · 2 min read

Myths about meditation, one by one

Some ideas about meditation get repeated so often they sound like rules: you must empty your mind, sit cross-legged, it always relaxes you, or science has proven it. Here is each one, checked against a text of the practice or a study, with what you can honestly say instead.

"Meditating means emptying your mind"

Descriptions of the practices say otherwise. NCCIH, the U.S. National Institutes of Health center that studies complementary approaches, talks about holding focus on a sensation such as the breath, a sound, an image or a phrase, or keeping attention on the present moment without judging. None of them asks you to empty anything.

The Satipaṭṭhāna Sutta (Majjhima Nikāya 10) teaches noticing what is there: someone with desire in them "discerns, 'There is sensual desire present within me.'" What is present gets noticed, not erased. And a wandering mind is the norm: Killingsworth and Gilbert found in 2,250 adults that their minds were on something other than what they were doing 46.9 percent of the time.

"You have to sit cross-legged"

The Ānāpānasati Sutta describes a monk sitting "folding his legs crosswise" with his body erect. But the text on the foundations of mindfulness (Majjhima Nikāya 10) teaches knowing that you are walking when you walk, standing when you stand, and likewise sitting and lying down. One tradition's posture is not a condition for practicing.

What most approaches share is something else: being awake in the body and able to hold the position for a while. A chair, the floor or walking can all do that.

"It is religious" and "it is not religious"

Both sentences are too simple. According to NCCIH, many techniques began in Eastern traditions, with a history of thousands of years. Lindahl and colleagues' 2017 study interviewed practitioners and experts in the Theravāda, Zen and Tibetan traditions, and that root is still visible in the words and the practices.

At the same time, the practice is taught in courses without religious content. Kabat-Zinn's, described in 1982, was a behavioral medicine program for people with chronic pain. That something has religious origins does not oblige you to practice it as a religion, and each person decides how they relate to that.

"It always relaxes you"

Sometimes it does, and sometimes it brings anxiety, sadness or memories. In 2020, Farias and colleagues reviewed 83 studies with 6,703 people and estimated a pooled adverse-event rate of 8.3 percent: anxiety, depression and cognitive changes were the most common. In 2019, Schlosser and colleagues asked 1,232 regular meditators, and 25.6 percent said they had had particularly unpleasant experiences they thought were related to their practice.

Lindahl and colleagues found that experiences ranged from very positive to very negative, and that two people can interpret the same experience very differently. There is more in the article on unwanted effects.

"Science has proven it"

Goyal and colleagues (2014) found moderate evidence of improvement in anxiety, depression and pain, with small effects, and no evidence that it was better than other active treatments. Van Dam and 14 co-authors wrote in 2018 that the field has had weak methods and exaggerated claims. "Proven" promises more than the studies say.

"It replaces treatment"

NCCIH is clear: do not use meditation to replace conventional medical care or as a reason to postpone seeing a health care provider about a medical problem. If you already receive care, tell your health team and whoever guides your practice.

Common questions

What is the most common myth about meditating?

Probably that you have to stop your thoughts. The practices ask you to notice your attention and return to the object, not to wipe the mind, and the mind wanders almost half the time in daily life.

Can I meditate in a chair or lying down?

Yes. The classical texts mention walking, standing, sitting and lying down. If you lie down, you are more likely to fall asleep.

Is meditation a religion?

It does not have to be. Many practices come from religious traditions, and they are also taught in programs with no religious content. You can decide what place it has in your life.

Sources

To practice

Keep reading