What has been studied
Nearly all the research is about programs, not meditation in general. The best known is mindfulness-based stress reduction, a group course of several weeks that Jon Kabat-Zinn started at the University of Massachusetts in 1979. A program mixes meditation, body exercises, group conversation and home practice, so an effect cannot be pinned on one practice.
The U.S. National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) puts it this way: the studies examined many different types of practices, so findings are tricky to interpret. When someone says meditation does something, it is worth asking which practice, for how long, and compared with what.
What the reviews found
In 2014, Goyal and colleagues reviewed 47 trials with 3,515 participants in JAMA Internal Medicine, all with an active comparison group. They found moderate evidence of improvement in anxiety, depression and pain for mindfulness programs, and low evidence for stress and mental health-related quality of life. The effects were small: about 0.38 for anxiety at eight weeks and 0.22 at three to six months; 0.30 and 0.23 for depression; 0.33 for pain. "Moderate" describes how much confidence the studies justify, not how large the effect is.
In 2018, Goldberg and colleagues pooled 142 samples with 12,005 participants who had psychiatric disorders. Mindfulness-based programs beat no treatment (d = 0.55) and minimal treatment (0.37), had smaller advantages over active comparisons (0.35 and 0.23), and did not differ from established evidence-based treatments. The strongest evidence was for depression, pain, smoking and addictive disorders.
NCCIH summarizes something similar: mindfulness approaches did better than no treatment for anxiety and depression, and about as well as evidence-based therapies.
What they did not find
The Goyal review found no evidence that meditation programs were better than other active treatments, such as drugs, exercise or other behavioral therapies. Nor did it find solid evidence of effects on attention, sleep, positive mood, substance use, eating habits or weight: the evidence was weak or insufficient.
NCCIH adds what remains unknown: long-term effects, since few studies follow people past a few months, and which types of practice work best. It also warns that results may have been interpreted too optimistically, and that much of the research has been preliminary or not scientifically rigorous. A 2021 analysis it mentions showed mixed short-term results for anxiety, and the few studies that followed people for more than two months found no long-term effects.
Why it is hard to study well
- The comparison group. People who meditate know they are meditating, and there is no fake meditation equivalent to a sugar pill. Effects change with what you compare against: in Goldberg's analysis the effect versus no treatment was 0.55, and versus a specific active comparison, 0.23.
- Questionnaires. Many outcomes are self-reports, and people who practice may say they feel better because they expect to.
- Programs vary. Different lengths, teachers and practices get averaged into one number.
- What gets published. In many fields positive results are published more often than null ones. It is a risk to keep in mind, though I am not citing a figure for meditation.
- Enthusiasm. Van Dam and 14 co-authors wrote a critique in 2018, Mind the Hype, noting that the field has suffered from weak methods and exaggerated claims, and calling for better studies.
Unwanted effects
People often say meditation has no risks, and that is not quite true. In 2020, Farias and colleagues reviewed 83 studies with 6,703 people who meditated: 55 of those studies (65 percent) reported at least one adverse event. The pooled rate was 8.3 percent, with a large gap by design: 3.7 percent in experimental studies and 33.2 percent in observational ones. The most common were anxiety, depression and cognitive changes, and the authors note they can occur in people with no history of mental health problems.
That gap between 3.7 and 33.2 percent shows how much the number depends on how people are asked. NCCIH says meditation is usually considered low-risk but that few studies have looked for harm, and advises against using it to replace health care or to delay seeing a provider.
How to read a headline about meditation
Check first what was studied: an eight-week program is not ten minutes on a cushion. Check what it was compared with, how many people took part and what was measured. Be wary of any sentence that promises a sure result.
What you can honestly say is this: there is evidence of small to moderate effects for some conditions, many people find the practice worthwhile, and it is neither a treatment nor a replacement for one. That is also a good reason to practice without expectations.
Common questions
Is meditation scientifically proven?
It depends what you ask. There is moderate evidence of improvement in anxiety, depression and pain from mindfulness programs, with small effects, and weak or insufficient evidence for other things such as attention or sleep.
Is it better than therapy or medication?
The reviews did not find that it is. Compared with evidence-based treatments, results were similar, not better. It should not be used to replace health care.
Can meditation harm me?
In some people it can bring anxiety, sadness or other difficult experiences. A 2020 review estimated 8.3 percent had adverse events, with a very wide range across studies. You can stop whenever you want, and if it happens often, talk to a mental health professional.
Why do studies seem to say so many different things?
Because they study different programs, with different comparisons and different measures. An effect against "doing nothing" tends to look larger than one against another activity.
Sources
- Goyal et al. (2014), Meditation programs for psychological stress and well-being, JAMA Internal Medicine 174(3)
- Goldberg et al. (2018), meta-analysis of mindfulness-based interventions for psychiatric disorders, Clinical Psychology Review 59
- Farias et al. (2020), systematic review of adverse events in meditation, Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 142(5)
- Van Dam et al. (2018), Mind the Hype, Perspectives on Psychological Science 13(1)
- NCCIH, U.S. National Institutes of Health: Meditation and Mindfulness, What You Need To Know