Meditate

Background · 3 min read

Meditation, stress and anxiety: what has been measured

Stress and anxiety are the most common reasons to start meditating, and the most studied. The results are modest and varied: small to moderate effects, smaller advantages when compared with other activities, and almost nothing showing it beats an established treatment. Here is what was measured, how, and with what limits.

What is measured, and how

Most studies evaluate programs of several weeks, not single sessions, and most measure with questionnaires people fill out about themselves. That is useful, but it is not the same as an objective measure, and people who practice may expect to feel better. It is always worth asking what the program was compared with: nothing, a similar activity or an established treatment.

The figures below are effect sizes. A value near 0.2 counts as small, near 0.5 as moderate, and near 0.8 as large.

Stress in people without a diagnosis

In 2015, Khoury and colleagues reviewed 29 studies with 2,668 healthy adults who took the MBSR program. The before-and-after effect was moderate (g = 0.55). The authors conclude the program appears moderately effective for stress, depression, anxiety and distress in healthy people, and that it remains to be learned which parts of the program do the work. A before-and-after comparison is not the same as one with a control group, so the figure describes a change, not how much of it the program caused.

Anxiety and depression

Goyal and colleagues (2014, 47 trials with 3,515 people) found moderate evidence of improvement in anxiety and depression from meditation programs and low evidence for stress, with small effects, and no evidence they were better than other active treatments.

Goldberg and colleagues (2018) pooled 142 samples with 12,005 participants who had psychiatric disorders. Mindfulness-based programs beat no treatment (d = 0.55), minimal treatment (0.37) and active comparisons (0.35 and 0.23), and did not differ from established evidence-based treatments (d = −0.004). The evidence was most consistent for depression, pain, smoking and addictive disorders.

NCCIH adds that a 2021 analysis showed mixed short-term results for anxiety, and that the few studies that followed people for more than two months found no long-term effects.

Preventing relapse in depression

Mindfulness-based cognitive therapy (MBCT) is a different program, made for people with recurrent depression. In 2016, Kuyken and colleagues pooled data from 9 trials with 1,258 people and saw that at 60 weeks those who took MBCT had a lower risk of relapse than those who did not (hazard ratio 0.69) and than those given other active treatments, antidepressants among them (0.79). The authors note that the benefit appears larger when there are more residual symptoms, and call for more trials to settle the remaining uncertainties.

Post-traumatic stress

NCCIH describes a 2018 trial, funded by the U.S. Department of Defense, of 203 veterans with service-related PTSD: meditation was as effective as prolonged exposure therapy at reducing PTSD and depression symptoms, and more effective than health education. It is one trial, and this is an area to approach with professionals, not on your own.

What the studies do not say

They do not say meditation is better than therapy or medication, or that it replaces health care: NCCIH asks people not to use it to replace care or postpone seeing a provider. They do not say how much to practice either, and I found no source that sets a minimum dose. And as in the rest of this field, comparisons matter: the more similar the control activity, the smaller the advantage.

If your anxiety or stress limits your day, talk with a health professional. Meditation can accompany that, but it is a practice, not a treatment.

Common questions

Does meditation reduce stress?

A review of 29 studies in healthy people found a moderate effect of the MBSR program. Another review, of 47 trials, rated the evidence for stress as low. Results depend on the program and on the comparison.

Does it help with anxiety?

There is moderate evidence of improvement with small effects, and mixed short-term results in a 2021 analysis, with no long-term effects in the few studies that followed people past two months.

Is it better than medication or therapy?

The reviews did not find that it is: in comparisons with established treatments, results were similar.

How many minutes a day does it take?

No source I reviewed sets a minimum dose. The studies evaluate programs of several weeks with regular practice.

Sources

To practice

Keep reading