Meditate

Background · 3 min read

Mindfulness and meditation are not the same thing

People use them as synonyms, and they are not. Meditation is the general name for many practices, mindfulness is one of them, and programs such as MBSR or MBCT are structured courses that use mindfulness. Knowing the difference helps you read what studies and ads are actually saying.

Three different levels

It helps to separate three things. Meditation is the whole family of practices that train attention or the mind. Mindfulness is one specific way of practicing, and also a term used for a quality of attention. And MBSR and MBCT are programs of several weeks that teach mindfulness along with other things.

NCCIH, a center of the U.S. National Institutes of Health, sums it up this way: mindfulness is maintaining attention or awareness on the present moment without making judgments, and programs such as MBSR and MBCT add group discussion and skill-building.

Where the word comes from

"Mindfulness" is an English rendering of the Pali word sati. Access to Insight's glossary defines it as mindfulness, self-collectedness, powers of reference and retention, and adds that in some contexts the word on its own also covers alertness. It is one of the qualities taught in the oldest Buddhist texts.

The text usually cited as its basis, the Satipaṭṭhāna Sutta (Majjhima Nikāya 10), speaks of four frames of reference: the body, feelings, the mind and mental qualities. That is wider than "being in the present," and some scholars debate how much of the modern idea fits the original meaning. That discussion is still open among specialists and I will not settle it here.

Programs: MBSR and MBCT

Mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR) was developed by Jon Kabat-Zinn at the University of Massachusetts. In 1982 he published in General Hospital Psychiatry the first data from a 10-week program with 51 people who had chronic pain. It was a preliminary study with no comparison group, so it explains the approach's origin and is not proof.

Mindfulness-based cognitive therapy (MBCT) was designed for people with recurrent depression. In 2016, Kuyken and colleagues pooled individual data from 9 randomized trials with 1,258 patients. Over 60 weeks, people who received MBCT had a lower risk of relapse than those who did not (hazard ratio 0.69) and than those who received other active treatments, antidepressants among them (0.79). The authors concluded it appears effective, particularly for people with more residual symptoms.

Not all meditation is mindfulness

NCCIH separates focused attention, which holds focus on a sensation, sound, image or repeated phrase, from mindfulness, which observes what arises without judging. Repeating a mantra or fixing your gaze on a flame is closer to the first. Other practices, such as loving-kindness or a body scan, have their own names and aims.

Nor is all mindfulness sitting. The text cited above teaches knowing that you are walking when you walk, and likewise standing, sitting or lying down.

Why it matters when you read studies

Nearly all the research is about programs, not a short stretch of practice. In 2014, Goyal and colleagues reviewed 47 trials with 3,515 people and found moderate evidence of improvement in anxiety, depression and pain from meditation programs, and weak or insufficient evidence for other effects. They were not better than other active treatments.

So "mindfulness reduces stress" usually means "an eight-week program, with a teacher, a group and homework, lowered stress scores on questionnaires, compared with something." Whether ten minutes of breathing alone does the same is another question, and those studies do not answer it.

Common questions

Are mindfulness and meditation the same?

No. Meditation is the family of practices; mindfulness is one of them, centered on attention to the present without judging. Some meditations are not mindfulness, such as repeating a phrase.

What is MBSR?

It is a program of several weeks with meditation, body exercises, group conversation and home practice, created by Jon Kabat-Zinn at the University of Massachusetts. It is a course, not a single technique.

What is MBCT?

It is a group therapy that combines mindfulness with elements of cognitive therapy, designed to prevent relapse in recurrent depression. It is a therapy, so a single stand-alone session is not a substitute for it.

Is mindfulness religious?

The word comes from the Buddhist tradition, and current programs are taught without religious content. Each person decides how to relate to that origin.

Sources

To practice

Keep reading