Meditate

Attention

Open awareness meditation

You start with the breath so attention can settle, then you let it go: you notice whatever appears, a sound, a sensation, a thought, and let it pass without following it. It is a practice for people who have already tried focused attention, and it takes ten, twenty or thirty minutes.

10 min20 min30 min

Getting ready

  1. Sit on a chair or a cushion, with your back upright but not stiff. For this practice sitting works better than lying down, because wide attention invites sleep.
  2. Rest your hands still on your legs or together in your lap.
  3. Close your eyes or let your gaze rest low and loose, not fixed on any point.
  4. If at some point the openness feels disorienting, come back to the breath for a few breaths. That is part of the practice, not a step back.
  5. If you need to move, do it slowly. A bell rings at the end; stay for a few seconds before you get up.

The full script

This is what you will hear. Between one line and the next there are silences; they are part of the practice.

Sit so that your back holds itself up, without stiffness. Close your eyes if you like. Or let your gaze rest low and loose. Let your hands rest still, on your legs or together. Notice your whole body here. Its weight, its shape. Start with something simple. Notice the breath, without changing it. Feel a few breaths come in and go out. The breath is only a starting point. Later you will let it go. If your mind wanders, come back to the air. That is how attention settles.

Now widen a little. Notice the breath and, at the same time, the whole body. Sensations in your hands, in your face, where your body meets the seat. Widen a little more. Let sounds in too. Breath, body and sounds, all at once, without picking one.

Now let go of the breath as a fixed point. There is no place your attention has to be. Just notice what appears. A sound, a sensation, a thought.

And notice how it changes or goes.

No need to follow anything or push anything away. What comes, comes. What goes, goes.

Thoughts belong here too. Notice them the way you notice a sound, something that appears and passes.

At some point a thought will carry you off. That is what minds do. The moment you notice, you are already back. Keep noticing what appears now.

If the openness feels disorienting, come back to the breath for a few breaths. Then open again.

If anything becomes too much, open your eyes or move. You can stop whenever you want. Keep going on your own. No fixed object. Just noticing what appears.

You may notice some things pull you in and others annoy you. Notice that too, without changing it.

Notice the gaps. The silence between two sounds, the pause between two thoughts.

There is nothing to achieve. Nothing special has to happen.

If you drifted, no scolding. Rest on the breath a moment and open again.

Go on by yourself. The voice will come back in a while.

What appears comes and goes. You just notice it.

Keep going, in silence.

Now come back to the breath. A few breaths in and out. Notice your body on the seat, its weight, its edges. Notice the sounds around you. Slowly move your fingers and your toes. When you are ready, open your eyes. Let your gaze open to the room as well. That is all. What you noticed here keeps appearing and passing for the rest of the day.

What it is

This is a practice with no fixed object. In breath meditation you pick one thing and return to it; here you do not pick. You notice whatever shows up in the moment, a sound, an ache in your knee, a memory, and let it pass without following it or pushing it away. What you practice is how you are with all of that, not a place to put your attention.

This version begins with a few minutes on the breath and opens up step by step: first the body, then sounds, and finally anything that appears. When the openness feels disorienting, the breath is still there as a place to come back to for a moment.

Where it comes from

Several traditions have something similar, and it is worth not blending them. Sōtō Zen has shikantaza, usually translated as "just sitting". Dōgen, in thirteenth-century Japan, took the phrase from his Chinese teacher Rujing, who used it for the silent illumination that Hongzhi Zhengjue had taught a century earlier. In shikantaza you do not count breaths or work with a koan, a phrase to contemplate: you take the posture and stay awake to what is there. It is a practice inside a tradition, with its posture, its community and its teacher, and this meditation does not replace it.

Choiceless awareness is something else. The phrase belongs to Jiddu Krishnamurti, who spoke about it from the 1930s on. For him no technique could get you there: he rejected meditation methods, though he valued meditation itself. A guided meditation, with instructions and steps, is not what he was proposing.

In research, Antoine Lutz, Heleen Slagter, John Dunne and Richard Davidson proposed in 2008, in Trends in Cognitive Sciences, to tell apart two styles: focused attention, held on a chosen object, and open monitoring, a non-reactive watching of whatever comes up, with no explicit object. They note that the second usually starts with the first, to calm the mind. This meditation follows that order.

What people use it for

Many people come to open awareness after some time with the breath, when returning to the same spot again and again starts to feel narrow. It helps them see how the mind works in general: what draws it, what bothers it, what sweeps it away.

People also use it on days when fighting distractions is exhausting. Here there is no such thing as a distraction: a thought is one more thing that appears. And some use it to close other practices, a few minutes of wide attention before going back to the day.

What studies say

The Lutz paper is a theoretical framework built from traditional texts and neuroscience; it is not a trial with results. Few studies compare open awareness on its own with anything else, and many use small groups.

What has been studied most are multi-week mindfulness programs that combine focused and open practices. A 2014 review in JAMA Internal Medicine pooled 47 trials with 3,515 participants and found moderate evidence of improvement in anxiety, depression and pain, and insufficient evidence about attention. There is no way to tell how much of the effect comes from open awareness.

What you may notice

At first it is common not to know what to do without a fixed point. The mind looks for something to hold on to, or slips into a thought and stays there without noticing. That is not a mistake: it is the first thing this practice shows you.

Wide attention also invites sleep and daydreaming, especially in long sessions. If that happens, open your eyes, straighten your back or come back to the breath for a few breaths before opening again.

Sometimes, with no object to hold attention, memories or emotions come up more strongly. You can come back to the breath, your hands or sounds, open your eyes or stop. Doing so is not failing.

Which length to choose

All three lengths say the same words; what grows is the silence, mostly in the open part. In ten minutes there is time to settle and open for a while. In twenty the open part is long and the voice appears rarely. In thirty almost the whole session is silence.

If you have never practiced open awareness, start with ten, ideally after a few weeks of a focused practice such as the breath or counting breaths. Move to twenty when the silences in ten start to feel short.

Common mistakes

  • Mistaking open for scattered. Attention is awake and present; it just does not fix on one thing.
  • Looking for a special state of spaciousness or calm. Noticing what is there is enough.
  • Following each thought to its end. Notice it as something that appears and let it pass.
  • Skipping the opening part. A few minutes with the breath make it easier to open later.
  • Thinking that going back to the breath is cheating. It is a support the practice builds in.

Keep in mind

  • With no fixed object, memories or emotions can come up more strongly. Come back to the breath or to sounds, open your eyes or stop whenever you want.
  • In long sessions sleep comes easily. Sitting upright with your eyes half open helps.
  • If you live with trauma or strong emotional distress, talk to a mental health professional first.

Common questions

What is open awareness meditation?

It is a way of meditating with no fixed object. Instead of always returning to the breath, you notice what shows up, sounds, sensations or thoughts, and let it pass. In research it is called open monitoring.

Is it the same as shikantaza?

Not quite. *Shikantaza* is the "just sitting" of Sōtō Zen, with its own posture, context and teaching, and it is learned inside that tradition. This meditation borrows a related idea, having no fixed object, but it is a guided, secular practice.

What about Krishnamurti's choiceless awareness?

Not that either. Krishnamurti used the phrase for a way of being present that, in his view, no technique can produce. A meditation with instructions is a method by definition, so it is not what he described.

Can I start with open awareness?

You can, but many people find it easier after some time with a focused practice. That is why this version begins with the breath. If you get lost a lot, go back to breath meditation or counting breaths and return to this one later.

Sources