Meditate

Kind of meditation

Open awareness: watching without choosing an object

In open awareness there is no object to return to: attention stays available for whatever comes, a sound, a sensation or a thought. Three ideas often get blended under that name: Zen's *shikantaza*, the research category of "open monitoring" and Krishnamurti's "choiceless awareness". They are not the same, and this page shows how they differ.

What it is

In an object meditation, such as following the breath, attention keeps returning to one spot. In open awareness there is no such spot. You watch what happens as it happens, without holding on to it and without pushing it away.

There is no right thing to find and no state to reach: the instruction, in all three senses, is to stay present with what is. It is hard to explain because the name is used in three senses from three different worlds: a Zen practice, a scientific category and a philosophical idea.

Shikantaza: the Zen practice

Shikantaza (只管打坐) is Dōgen's Japanese reading of the Chinese zhǐguǎn dǎzuò, usually translated "just sitting". It is associated with the Sōtō school. There is no specific object like the breath: you stay in awareness of the present, in the posture of zazen.

Its Chinese lineage is "silent illumination" (mòzhào), the hallmark of the Caodong school. According to Wikipedia, the master Hongzhi Zhengjue (1091–1157) was the first to put it in writing, and Dōgen's teacher Rujing used the phrase for it. Dōgen describes it as doing only zazen with your whole being, and the state is called "dropping off body and mind" (shinjin datsuraku).

Open monitoring: the scientific category

In 2008 Lutz, Slagter, Dunne and Davidson sorted meditations in Trends in Cognitive Sciences into two families. In focused attention you voluntarily direct attention to a chosen object. In open monitoring there is "non-reactive monitoring of the content of experience from moment to moment".

This is a category for ordering practices, drawn from traditional texts and neuroscience. It is a theoretical review, not a clinical trial, and a real practice often mixes the two.

Choiceless awareness: Krishnamurti

Jiddu Krishnamurti (1895–1986) began speaking of "choiceless awareness" in the 1930s: a complete awareness of the present, without preference, effort or compulsion. In 1980 he wrote: "Freedom is found in the choiceless awareness of our daily existence and activity."

The key difference is that Krishnamurti offered no technique. He held that a technique cannot produce that awareness and that every method introduces conflict. He rejected techniques of meditation, not meditation itself. Other traditions use the phrase differently: Chögyam Trungpa applied it to śūnyatā, emptiness, and in shikantaza it is often described as a fruit of mature practice.

How it differs from other meditations

Shikantaza and open monitoring are not synonyms: one is a method with its tradition and posture, the other a research label. Comparing one with the other is interpretation. Nor is it vipassana: the Burmese vipassana of Mahasi uses mental labels ("rising, falling"), and open awareness does not. And it differs from samatha, which concentrates attention on a single object.

What studies say

Lutz and colleagues' paper is a theoretical framework: it does not measure effects. There is no solid evidence that says what open awareness does in particular. Reviews of mindfulness programs, which include monitoring practices, find moderate evidence of improvement in anxiety, depression and pain, with small effects.

With no object to return to, it is normal for the mind to wander off with a thought and take a while to notice. When you notice, nothing went wrong: go back to watching. If anything becomes too much, you can open your eyes or stop.

Common questions

What is open awareness meditation?

It is meditating without choosing an object: attention stays available for whatever appears. Researchers call it open monitoring, and in Zen one of its forms is *shikantaza*.

Are shikantaza and open awareness the same?

Not exactly. Shikantaza is a Zen method with its own posture and tradition; open awareness is a broader category. Comparing one with the other is interpretation.

What is choiceless awareness?

It is Krishnamurti's phrase for a complete awareness of the present, without preference or effort. He gave no technique for it and said techniques cannot produce it.

Is open awareness better than following the breath?

Studies do not let us say so. They are two different ways of meditating that you can alternate depending on what you are looking for.

Sources

To practice something similar here