Meditate

Practical guide · 3 min read

What to do when your mind won't stop

When you meditate and your mind will not stop, the practice is working the way it usually works: you are seeing the mind. The aim is not to stop thoughts but to notice when you have left and come back to an anchor. Here is what to do in the moment, what one study says about how often minds wander, and when to try something else.

What a distraction is, and what it isn't

A distraction is the moment your attention leaves the spot you chose, the breath, a sound or your hands, and goes off to a plan, a memory or an imaginary conversation. It takes seconds, and you almost never catch it while it is happening.

What counts as practice is what comes next: noticing and returning. That is why a session full of thoughts is not a failed session. If you drifted ten times in five minutes, you came back ten times.

How much the mind wanders, according to one study

Killingsworth and Gilbert asked 2,250 people aged 18 to 88, through a phone app at random times, what they were doing and what they were thinking about. They reported in Science in 2010 that minds were on something other than the task at hand about 47 percent of the time, and that what people were thinking about predicted their mood better than what they were doing.

Read it carefully. It measured daily life, not meditation, and it is an observational study: it shows an association between wandering and feeling worse, not that wandering is bad in itself. What matters for you is that a mind that leaves is not a quirk of yours. It is the usual state.

What to do in the moment

  • Note it and return. When you realize you drifted, say "thinking" silently and go back to the breath. No scolding, no analyzing the thought.
  • Pick a clearer anchor. If the breath is faint, try the sounds around you or your hands resting on your legs: sensations you do not have to search for.
  • Count. Count each out-breath from one to ten, then start over. If you lose count, go back to one; that is the practice too.
  • Open up a little. If wrestling with one topic wears you out, rest your attention on the whole body or the sounds around you instead of a single point.
  • Move. Open your eyes, stretch your back or switch to a walking meditation. A very loaded mind sometimes settles better in motion.

What doesn't help

Trying to empty your mind usually brings more thoughts, because you are standing guard against them. Grading the session or comparing it with yesterday's does not help either.

The old Buddhist texts already named the problem. The Satipatthana Sutta lists five hindrances, restlessness and drowsiness among them, and its instruction begins with recognizing when one is present: the practitioner knows "there is restlessness in me" or "there is no restlessness in me." It is a teaching from a tradition, not a clinical classification. As a practical idea, naming what is happening comes first, before you do anything else.

What studies say about attention

It would be convenient to say meditation improves attention, but the evidence is more modest. The 2014 review by Goyal and colleagues in JAMA Internal Medicine, with 47 trials and 3,515 participants, found low evidence of no effect on attention, or insufficient evidence to show one. That describes programs lasting several weeks, compared with other treatments, not one person trying a week.

So it is wiser not to expect a quiet mind from the practice. What you are exercising is something else: noticing what shows up and returning.

When the thoughts are heavy

A to-do list is one thing. A thought that loops and hurts is another. If sitting brings up worries or memories that leave you feeling worse, open your eyes, look around the room, press your feet into the floor and leave the session for another time. Stopping is a valid choice.

The U.S. National Institutes of Health cautions that meditation should not replace health care. If this happens often, or you live with trauma or strong emotional distress, talk to a mental health professional first.

Common questions

Is it normal that I can't stop thinking when I meditate?

Yes. It happens to almost everyone, especially at the start. The practice is not to stop thinking but to notice you drifted and come back.

Does meditation work if my mind is very fast?

You can practice with a fast mind, and the exercise is actually easier to see there. Try short sessions, an anchor with clear sensations such as sounds or your hands, or counting out-breaths.

How many times is it normal to get distracted in a session?

There is no normal number. Dozens of times in a few minutes is common. Each time you come back counts as a return, not a failure.

Should I stop meditating if I think a lot?

Not necessarily. If the thoughts distress you, stop that session and try something else, such as a walking meditation. If it happens often, talk to a mental health professional.

Sources

To practice

Keep reading