The list
In Pali, the language of the oldest texts of Theravada Buddhism, they are called nīvaraṇa, "hindrances" or "obstacles." The Access to Insight glossary defines them as hindrances to concentration: sensual desire, ill will, sloth and drowsiness, restlessness and anxiety, and uncertainty.
In today's words: wanting something that is not here (distraction by craving, fantasy or pleasure), pushing away what is here (anger, irritation, aversion), sinking into heaviness and sleep, being unable to settle inside, and doubting the practice, yourself, or whether any of this is worthwhile.
What the text says: first, notice
In the Satipaṭṭhāna Sutta (MN 10), in Thanissaro Bhikkhu's translation, you are not told to get rid of the hindrances. You are told to notice whether they are there. When sensual desire is present, the person discerns: "There is sensual desire present within me," and the same for each of the others. When it is absent, they recognize that too.
That is the central idea of the list: before doing anything about restlessness or sleepiness, see that it is there. Many people find that naming it ("this is restlessness") already changes their relation to it, though that is a common experience, not something studies have shown.
What feeds them and what starves them
Another text, the Āhāra Sutta (SN 46.51), speaks of what "feeds" each hindrance and what leaves it without food. In Thanissaro's translation, sensual desire is fed by attending to the "theme of beauty" and weakened by attending to its opposite. Ill will is fed by attending to what irritates, and weakened by goodwill, compassion, appreciation or equanimity. Sloth and drowsiness are fed by attending to boredom, weariness and yawning, and weakened by effort and exertion. Restlessness is fed by attending to the non-stillness of the mind, and weakened by stilling it. Doubt is fed by attending to what gives it a foothold, and weakened by carefully telling the skillful from the unskillful.
What the text shows is a practical idea: where attention goes is part of what feeds a hindrance. You do not need to accept the whole tradition to see that this makes sense.
What people usually do with each
- Desire: note "planning" or "wanting," and return to the breath. You do not need to judge yourself for the plan.
- Anger or aversion: find where it sits in the body. A kind thought toward yourself, or loving-kindness practice, can help.
- Sleepiness: open your eyes, straighten your back, sit instead of lying down, or meditate at another time of day.
- Restlessness: pause to move calmly, or try walking meditation. Stay with the sensation in the body without fighting it.
- Doubt: remember that doubting is common and that you can try for a while without committing to anything. Ask someone with more experience.
What studies say, and what they do not
The list of five is a Buddhist teaching framework, not a clinical classification. No studies validate it as such. There is research on distraction in general: in 2010, Killingsworth and Gilbert (Science) used a phone app to sample what people were thinking during the day, and found that minds wandered often and that, on average, this went with less happiness. They measured daily life, not meditation, and a study like that cannot say what causes what.
In a 2017 study, Lindahl and colleagues interviewed practitioners from the Theravada, Zen and Tibetan traditions and described 59 difficult meditation-related experiences across seven domains (cognitive, perceptual, affective, somatic, conative, sense of self and social). Responses varied widely: from minimal, brief discomfort to severe and lasting distress.
When it is not just a hindrance
If restlessness, sadness or anger is very strong, it is not an obstacle to "overcome" in your chair. You can stop, open your eyes and move. If it happens often, or if there is a history of trauma or strong distress, talk first with a mental health professional.
Common questions
What are the five hindrances?
Sensual desire, ill will, sloth and drowsiness, restlessness and anxiety, and doubt. They come from the Pali texts and are used as a list of what tends to get in the way of concentration.
Am I supposed to get rid of them?
The text the list comes from asks you to notice them instead: to know when one is there and when it is not. It is not an exam you pass by having none.
Is it a medical classification?
No. It is a Buddhist teaching. It works as a map of experience, but it diagnoses nothing.
I always fall asleep when I meditate. Is that a hindrance?
Drowsiness is one of the five. People often try sitting instead of lying down, opening the eyes or changing the time. If it is real tiredness, resting is an answer too.
Sources
- Access to Insight, glossary: nīvaraṇa
- Satipaṭṭhāna Sutta (MN 10), translated by Thanissaro Bhikkhu, Access to Insight
- Āhāra Sutta, Food (SN 46.51), translated by Thanissaro Bhikkhu, Access to Insight
- Killingsworth and Gilbert (2010), A wandering mind is an unhappy mind, Science 330(6006)
- Lindahl et al. (2017), The varieties of contemplative experience, PLoS One 12(5)