Meditate

Background · 3 min read

Meditation and attention: what the studies show

Meditation trains attention, so it seems logical that it would improve it. The studies are less clear: some brief studies found gains on lab tests, and broader reviews found no solid evidence for eight-week programs. Here is what was measured, where the results conflict, and what is not known.

What attention means here

In a focused-attention practice you choose an object, such as the breath, and come back to it when your mind leaves. That trains one specific move: noticing you got distracted and returning. It is different from the "concentration" measured in a lab test, which is usually reacting quickly to a stimulus or ignoring a distracting one.

Getting distracted is normal. Killingsworth and Gilbert, using a phone app that asked 2,250 adults what they were doing and what they were thinking about, found their minds were on something else 46.9 percent of the time. The study was not about meditation, but it shows the starting point.

Brief studies with favorable results

In 2010, Zeidan and colleagues compared four sessions of meditation training with four sessions of listening to a recorded book in people with no experience. Afterward, those who meditated improved on visuo-spatial processing, working memory and executive functioning, and the authors conclude that four days can improve the ability to sustain attention. Both groups improved in mood; only the meditation group reduced fatigue and anxiety.

In 2007, Jha, Krompinger and Baime used the Attention Network Test to compare three groups: people with no experience or training, people who took an eight-week MBSR course, and experienced meditators on an intensive one-month retreat. The MBSR course improved orienting of attention; the retreat improved detection of outside stimuli. These are results about specific components of attention, measured with one specific test.

Reviews that do not confirm them

In 2016, Lao, Kissane and Meadows reviewed 18 studies of standardized eight-week programs (MBCT and MBSR) using objective neuropsychological tests. Overall, the studies did not support improvements in attention or executive function. They did find preliminary evidence of improvements in working memory, autobiographical memory, cognitive flexibility and meta-awareness. They conclude that short-term training did not enhance the attentional pathways theory expected.

The 2014 review by Goyal and colleagues, with 47 trials and 3,515 people, arrived at something similar: evidence that programs improve attention compared with active comparisons was weak or insufficient.

Why the studies disagree

  • Different training. Four sessions, eight weeks and a month-long retreat are not the same, and neither is watching the breath versus following a full program.
  • Different tests. "Attention" is measured with very different tasks, and a gain on one may not show up on another.
  • Different comparisons. One study compares with nothing and another with an equally interesting activity. Results change.
  • Different questions. Jha looked at specific components of attention; Lao looked at attention and executive function as a whole. An effect on one piece may not show in the total.

What can be said today

What can be said is that there are favorable results in specific studies, and that broader reviews found no solid evidence that eight-week programs improve attention measured with objective tests. It cannot be said that meditating "increases your concentration," or given as a percentage, and I did not find a reliable source that does.

It is also unknown whether what is measured in a lab shows up at work, in study or in conversation. Many people say they notice it, and that is a valid experience, though not a measurement. You can practice for what you notice yourself, with an open expectation.

Common questions

Does meditating improve concentration?

Some brief studies found gains on attention tests. A review of 18 studies of eight-week programs found no support for improvements in attention or executive function. The evidence is not conclusive.

How many days does it take to notice anything?

A small 2010 study measured changes after four sessions, but later reviews do not confirm a stable effect. No minimum amount has been established.

Is it normal for my mind to wander constantly?

Yes. In a study of 2,250 adults, minds were on something else almost half the time. Noticing you got distracted and returning is the practice.

Does it help with ADHD?

I found no evidence in the sources I reviewed that would allow saying so. If you have concerns about your attention, talk with a health professional.

Sources

To practice

Keep reading