Two things with the same name
When someone says "breathe and meditate," they may mean two practices. In the first, the breath is the object of attention and you do not change it: you notice it. In the second, the breath is what you do: you lengthen it, count it, pause it at a set rhythm.
The difference matters because they ask different things. The first trains attention and acceptance of what is there. The second trains control of a rhythm. Neither is better in general; they serve different purposes.
Attending to the natural breath
NCCIH, a center of the U.S. National Institutes of Health, gives breath awareness as an example of focused attention: holding mental focus on a sensation, such as breathing. Access to Insight's glossary defines ānāpānasati as mindfulness of breathing, a practice in which you keep your attention on the sensations of breathing.
The classical Buddhist text, the Ānāpānasati Sutta (Majjhima Nikāya 118), puts it this way in Thanissaro Bhikkhu's translation: breathing in long, one discerns "I am breathing in long"; breathing in short, "I am breathing in short." The breath is known as it is. The text goes on to further stages, such as training to breathe in sensitive to the entire body.
In this practice the air comes and goes on its own. When the mind goes elsewhere, you notice and return, without trying to make the breath deeper or slower.
Breathing exercises
Breathing exercises regulate the air on purpose. In the yoga tradition that regulation is called prāṇāyāma. Sūtra 2.49 of Patañjali, in a translation given on wisdomlib, defines it as regulation of the flow of inhalation and exhalation, including control of its speed or holding the breath.
There is research on slow breathing. In 2018, Zaccaro and colleagues reviewed 15 studies, chosen from 2,461 abstracts, in healthy people. They found changes in heart rate variability and in brain activity measured by EEG, with more alpha and less theta power, and descriptions of lower arousal, anxiety, depression and anger. Read it with care: it is a narrative review, not a meta-analysis, the pool of studies is small, and it covers only healthy people. The authors themselves say the mechanisms are still debated.
This article does not go further into that practice. Guided breathing exercises with a set rhythm are another practice, with their own safety questions. Holding the breath, in particular, is something to learn from someone who knows how to teach it.
What they share and what changes
Both use a sensation that is present and easy to find. Both can leave you feeling calm. But in the first, if your breath turns uneven, nothing is wrong: it is what is there and you observe it. In the second, the aim is to keep the rhythm, and unevenness is something you correct.
That explains something common: people who get tense when they "watch" their breathing. If paying attention to it agitates you, that is a sign another practice or another object may suit you better.
If the breath is uncomfortable
Some people find that attending to the air makes them anxious, or that they end up controlling it without meaning to. That is common and it has a way out: switch the object of attention to sounds, to your feet on the floor or to your hands, and come back to the breath another day, or never. If it happens a lot, or you feel dizzy or truly short of air, stop and talk to a health professional.
Common questions
Is meditating the same as breathing deeply?
Not necessarily. In attention to the natural breath you do not change the rhythm: you notice the air as it is. Breathing deeply on purpose is a breathing exercise.
What is the difference between meditation and breathing exercises?
In breath meditation the breath is the object and you do not control it. In a breathing exercise you regulate it with a rhythm. They are different practices, with different origins and different studies.
Is slow breathing backed by science?
There is a review of 15 studies in healthy people describing changes in heart rate, EEG and mood. The pool of studies is small and the mechanisms are still debated.
Why do I get tense when I pay attention to my breathing?
It happens. You can attend to something else, such as sounds or the contact of your feet, and try the breath later if you want.
Sources
- Ānāpānasati Sutta (MN 118), translated by Thanissaro Bhikkhu, Access to Insight
- Access to Insight, glossary (ānāpānasati)
- NCCIH, U.S. National Institutes of Health: Meditation and Mindfulness, What You Need To Know
- Yoga Sūtra 2.49 (prāṇāyāma), study and translation on wisdomlib
- Zaccaro et al. (2018), How breath-control can change your life: a systematic review on psycho-physiological correlates of slow breathing, Frontiers in Human Neuroscience 12