Meditate

Background · 3 min read

Unwanted effects of meditation

Meditation is usually calm, but sometimes it brings anxiety, sadness, fear or odd body sensations. That is no reason to avoid it, and nothing to hide: it is what has been documented. Here is how often it appears by type of study, what is known about who has it more, what institutions advise, and what you can do.

What has been documented

In 2020, Farias and colleagues reviewed studies of adverse events in meditation among adults: 83 studies with 6,703 people who meditated. In 55 of them (65 percent), at least one adverse event was reported. The most common were anxiety (33 percent of studies), depression (27 percent) and cognitive changes (25 percent), and the least common were gastrointestinal problems and suicidal behaviors. The authors conclude that these events are not rare and may occur in people with no history of mental health problems.

In 2017, Lindahl and colleagues interviewed practitioners and experts in the Theravāda, Zen and Tibetan traditions and described 59 meditation-related experiences across seven domains: cognitive, perceptual, affective, somatic, conative, sense of self and social. Their valence ranged from very positive to very negative, and the distress or impairment from minimal and passing to severe and lasting. The same experience was lived very differently by different people.

How often: it depends how you ask

Numbers vary a lot with design. In the Farias review the pooled rate was 8.3 percent: 3.7 percent in experimental studies and 33.2 percent in observational ones.

In 2021, Britton and colleagues used a detailed interview with 96 people after an eight-week mindfulness-based cognitive therapy program. Eighty-three percent had at least one meditation-related side effect; in 58 percent one was negative, and in 37 percent one had a negative impact on functioning. Lasting bad effects occurred in 6 to 14 percent. The authors note these are rates similar to other psychological treatments.

In two general-population samples taking an adaptation of that program (84 schoolteachers and 74 university students, with no comparison group), Baer and colleagues found that about two thirds had unpleasant experiences, that 85 to 92 percent rated them not at all or only somewhat upsetting, and that 3 to 7 percent said the course harmed them. Symptom questionnaires and the harm people reported almost never pointed to the same individuals.

Who seems more at risk

Not much is known yet. In 2019, Schlosser and colleagues asked 1,232 people with at least two months of regular practice: 25.6 percent said they had had particularly unpleasant experiences they thought their meditation caused. These were less likely in women and religious participants, and more likely in people with more repetitive negative thinking, in those who only did "deconstructive" types of meditation such as vipassana, and in those who had attended a retreat. It was a survey with a single question at a single time, so it cannot show causes.

Baer and colleagues propose that in programs, harm may relate to the program, to the participant and to the teacher, and that many trials do not ask about harm.

What institutions say

NCCIH says meditation and mindfulness are usually considered to have few risks, and that few studies have looked for harm. It advises not using them to replace medical care or to postpone seeing a provider, telling your health care providers about complementary approaches you use, and asking about the training and experience of whoever teaches. Its page does not name particular groups who should avoid it, and I will not present one as official guidance.

What you can do

  • Stopping is valid. You can open your eyes, move or end the session whenever you want.
  • Change the object of attention. If the breath or the body agitates you, try sounds or your feet on the floor, with your eyes open.
  • Shorten and space out. Brief sessions, every other day, are a reasonable choice.
  • Tell someone. Talking with someone you trust, or with whoever teaches you, helps, and much of what comes up is easier to carry when shared.
  • See a professional if what you feel lasts, interferes with work or sleep, or you have a history of trauma or strong distress. As this site's own precaution, in those cases it is wise to talk about it before you start.

Common questions

Can meditation harm me?

For some people it brings difficult experiences, and for a few, harm. Figures run from 3.7 percent in experimental studies to 33.2 percent in observational ones, according to a 2020 review. You can stop whenever you want.

What do I do if I get anxious while meditating?

Open your eyes, move your body, shift attention to sounds or your feet, or end the session. If it happens often or worries you, talk with a mental health professional.

Is meditating dangerous if I have had trauma?

The sources I consulted do not name groups who should avoid it. As a precaution, if you have a history of trauma or strong distress, talk with a mental health professional first and consider an in-person teacher.

Do difficult experiences mean I am doing it wrong?

No. Lindahl and colleagues describe that the same experience can be lived in very different ways, and that it is not automatically harm. If it affects you, taking a break is reasonable.

Sources

To practice

Keep reading