Meditate

Background · 3 min read

Does meditation change the brain? What is known

You often hear that meditating thickens the cortex or enlarges the hippocampus. The first studies did find differences, but they were small, and a much larger randomized trial published in 2022 found no structural change after eight weeks. Here is what each study measured, why the results do not agree, and what can be said today.

What is measured

Most of these studies use structural MRI: images of the size, thickness or density of brain regions. Measuring a difference is one thing and knowing what it means is another. A thicker region does not by itself show that it works better, and NCCIH puts it this way: some research suggests meditation may affect how the brain functions or is structured, but the practical implications are not clear.

The first findings

In 2005, Lazar and colleagues used MRI to compare cortical thickness in 20 people with extensive experience in insight meditation, a practice of attention to internal experience, with matched people who did not meditate. Regions associated with attention, interoception (sensing the body from inside) and sensory processing, including the prefrontal cortex and right anterior insula, were thicker in those who meditated. The prefrontal difference was larger in older participants, and thickness in two regions tracked years of practice.

This study is cross-sectional: it compares people who already meditated with people who did not. It cannot say that meditating caused the difference, because people who choose to meditate for years may have been different to begin with.

A study with eight weeks

In 2011, Hölzel and colleagues did something closer to an experiment. They scanned 16 people with no experience before and after an eight-week mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR) program, and compared them with 17 people on a waiting list. They found more gray matter concentration in the left hippocampus and, looking at the whole brain, in the posterior cingulate cortex, the temporo-parietal junction and the cerebellum.

It was a small sample, and the comparison group only waited: it did not do any similar activity.

The study that did not confirm it

In 2022, Kral and colleagues combined two three-arm randomized trials: 218 people with no experience, randomly assigned to a waitlist (70), an eight-week MBSR program (75) or a validated, matched active control (73). They measured gray matter volume, gray matter density and cortical thickness before and after.

The authors write that they failed to replicate prior findings: they found no evidence that MBSR produced structural changes compared with either control group, across the whole brain or in regions taken from earlier studies. They describe it as the largest and most rigorously controlled study to date, and note that earlier work had major methodological limitations.

How the two results sit together

It is not an unexplained contradiction: the 2011 study was small with a waitlist control, and the 2022 one was much larger with an active control. With small samples a finding can appear by chance and fail to repeat. This does not show that no one's brain ever changes, and it does not show that meditating is useless: the trial measured structure only, after eight weeks, of one specific program. What happens with many years of practice is still open, and studies of long-term meditators, like the one from 2005, still cannot separate cause from personal choice.

How to read a headline about the brain

If you read "meditation changes the brain," look at the study's design, how many people took part, whether there was an active comparison group and what was measured. A brain image sounds like proof, but it is worth no more than the design behind it. The honest statement today is that studies have given different results, and that the effect of an eight-week program on structure is not supported by the largest trial.

Common questions

Does meditating enlarge the hippocampus?

A small 2011 study found it after eight weeks of MBSR, but a 2022 trial with 218 people found no structural changes compared with two control groups. It cannot be claimed today.

Do veteran meditators have a different brain?

A 2005 study of 20 people found thicker regions in those with years of practice. Because it compared groups rather than running an experiment, it is not known whether the practice caused it.

Does a changed brain mean a better brain?

Not necessarily. NCCIH notes that the practical implications of these findings are not clear.

So meditation does not work?

The 2022 trial speaks only to brain structure after an eight-week program. Other questions, such as mood, sleep or stress, are studied with other methods and have other results.

Sources

To practice

Keep reading