Meditate

Background · 2 min read

Meditation and sleep: what the research says

Many people meditate to sleep better. The research finds some gains in sleep quality compared with activities that have no specific treatment effect, and no advantage over established treatments for insomnia. Here are the studies, with their size and limits, and what has not been studied.

What has been asked

There are two different questions. One is whether doing a meditation program for weeks improves the sleep you have. The other is whether a guided meditation right before bed helps you fall asleep that night. The studies I found answer almost only the first, and they measure sleep quality with questionnaires, not lab recordings.

A trial with older adults

Black and colleagues randomly assigned 49 older adults, average age 66 and with moderate sleep disturbances, to a mindful awareness practices program (24 people) or sleep hygiene education (25). Both were two hours a week for six weeks, with homework. On the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index, the mindfulness group went from 10.2 to 7.4 and the sleep hygiene group from 10.2 to 9.1: a between-group difference of 1.8 points (95 percent confidence interval 0.6 to 2.9; effect size 0.89).

The mindfulness group also improved more on insomnia symptoms, depression and fatigue. The authors describe a short-term improvement, right after the program. It is a small study, with a comparison that was not a therapy for insomnia, and it did not measure what happens months later.

What the reviews show

In 2019, Rusch and colleagues reviewed 18 trials with 1,654 people with sleep problems and separated two kinds of comparison. Against specific, established sleep treatments, meditation showed no effect, with low strength of evidence (effect size 0.03 at the end and −0.14 at follow-up). Against activities with no specific treatment effect, such as ones that match time and attention, there was an improvement in sleep quality with moderate strength of evidence (0.33 at the end and 0.54 at follow-up). The authors call the findings preliminary.

In 2016, Gong and colleagues analyzed six trials with 330 people with insomnia. Meditation mildly improved some sleep measures and not others, and the authors propose it as an add-on, not a substitute. NCCIH summarizes a 2019 analysis, Rusch's: mindfulness improved sleep quality more than education-based treatments, but no more than cognitive behavioral therapy or exercise.

The broad 2014 review by Goyal and colleagues found weak or no evidence of an effect on sleep.

What I could not confirm

For guided sleep meditations and deep relaxation practices, such as yoga nidra, I found no evidence I can cite here with confidence: what I saw were reviews with few trials and inconsistent results. Nor is there a reliable study behind labels like "deep rest without sleeping." If a practice gives you calm before bed, that is a valid experience, not a demonstrated result.

What to do with this

If you want to try, treat it as a practice and not a treatment. A meditation lying down may make you sleepy, and that is not a failure: it is common and welcome at that hour. If you wake up restless or with racing thoughts, you can return to the breath or to the feel of your body against the bed, without forcing sleep.

If several weeks go by with bad nights, or lack of sleep affects your day, talk with a health professional: insomnia has treatments with evidence behind them, and meditation should not be used to postpone that visit.

Common questions

Does meditating help you sleep better?

Some trials and reviews found mild to moderate improvements in sleep quality compared with activities with no specific treatment effect. No advantage was seen over cognitive behavioral therapy or other established treatments.

Can I fall asleep during a guided meditation?

It can happen, and it is not a failure. The studies I reviewed evaluate programs of several weeks, not a single session before bed.

Does it replace a treatment for insomnia?

No. If insomnia lasts or affects you, see a health professional. Meditation can accompany care, not replace it.

How long does it take to notice?

In the Black trial, changes were measured after six weeks of practice with homework. No minimum duration has been established.

Sources

To practice

Keep reading