Meditate

Kind of meditation

Samatha: the meditation of calm and concentration

Samatha means calm. It is the Buddhist practice of resting attention on one object, such as the breath, and coming back to it again and again until the mind settles. It underlies many simple meditations. Here is what the texts say, how it relates to vipassana, what the absorptions are and what research exists.

What it is

Samatha (Sanskrit śamatha) is translated as "calm", "serenity" or "tranquility of awareness". In Theravada commentary it is concentration: the ability to keep attention on a single object. In Tibetan it is shiné, with a sense of pacifying, slowing down and resting.

In a samatha session you pick an object, notice when attention has left and return. You are not looking for anything new to see. You are letting the mind settle enough to stay.

The objects of samatha

The Visuddhimagga, the great fifth-century manual by the monk Buddhaghosa, lists forty meditation objects. A classic one is the kasiṇa, a disc or an element such as earth, water or fire prepared to be looked at. According to Wikipedia, mindfulness of breathing (ānāpānasati) is the most common samatha practice, although the term is used for vipassana too.

The discourse on mindfulness of breathing (Majjhima Nikāya 118), in Thanissaro Bhikkhu's translation, sets out sixteen steps in four groups of four. It starts with noticing long and short breaths and moves to sensing the whole body and calming it. The tradition says that as concentration grows, the five hindrances, such as sleepiness and restlessness, are set aside.

The jhanas, in plain words

The Theravada account speaks of a "sign" (nimitta), a mental image that appears as concentration matures, and of access concentration. After that come four jhāna, states of absorption filled with deep joy (pīti). This is the most technical part of the path and is taught with a teacher.

There is no agreement on exactly what they are. Some scholars argue that jhāna involves heightened awareness, not a narrowed mind. Richard Gombrich holds that later tradition reduced it to calming concentration.

Samatha and vipassana

In present-day Theravada, samatha is often seen as preparation for vipassana: you calm the mind so insight can arise. Mahasi Sayadaw explains that the absorptions of samatha are worldly and that the path also requires wisdom. Some teachers in the vipassana movement say strong samatha can even be a disadvantage, a stance criticized especially in Sri Lanka.

Others read the texts differently. Thanissaro Bhikkhu writes that calm, absorption and insight are one path, and Ajahn Brahm that "calm leads to insight and insight leads to calm". According to Wikipedia, the early discourses pair the two qualities to be developed together, while the Abhidhamma and the commentaries treat them as two paths.

What studies say

Very few studies speak of samatha by that name. Research touches it sideways: in 2008 Lutz, Slagter, Dunne and Davidson proposed in Trends in Cognitive Sciences sorting meditations into focused attention, which holds attention on a chosen object, and open monitoring. It is a theoretical proposal drawn from texts and neuroscience, not a trial, and samatha resembles the first.

To learn what meditation does in general, look at the reviews of mindfulness programs, which show small effects and a moderate quality of evidence. If intense concentration brings anxiety or hard memories, you can stop, and it is worth talking to a professional.

Common confusions

Calm is not the only aim: the texts treat it as a base for something else. Concentrating is not the same as forcing: the practice asks you to return to the object kindly. And not all breath meditation is samatha: attention to breathing is also used in vipassana and in mindfulness.

Common questions

What does samatha mean?

It means calm, serenity or stillness of mind. It is the practice of concentrating on a single object, such as the breath, until the mind settles.

What is the difference between samatha and vipassana?

Samatha builds calm and concentration on one object; vipassana builds clear seeing of experience. In the tradition they usually go together, and there is debate about which comes first and how separate they are.

What are the jhanas?

They are states of absorption described in Buddhist texts, with very steady concentration and deep joy. They are taught with a teacher in the tradition, and scholars disagree about how to understand them.

Is breath meditation the same as samatha?

It can be. Following the breath with the aim of settling the mind is the most common samatha practice, but the same attention to breathing is used in vipassana and in mindfulness.

Sources

To practice something similar here