First: the posture is yours
The old texts describe the practitioner sitting on the ground, legs crossed, body upright. In the Ānāpānasati Sutta (MN 118) it appears in a monastic scene, in a forest or under a tree. It isn't a rule for everyone. The Satipaṭṭhāna Sutta (MN 10) lists four postures for practicing attention: walking, standing, sitting and lying down.
A chair with your feet on the floor is a complete posture. So is a cushion, a low bench, or lying on your back, knowing that sleep comes easily there. Pick the one you can hold without pain.
The most common discomforts
- Tired back. This often happens when you strain to hold yourself rigid. Lengthen your spine without stiffening, or lean on the chair back. If it continues, change posture.
- Numb legs. Holding one position for a while can cut off sensation and cause pins and needles. Stretch your legs slowly and wait for feeling to return before you put weight on them. Sitting on a chair or raising your seat usually prevents it.
- Aching knees or hips. Don't force them. A higher cushion, a chair or a bench takes the load off.
- Neck and shoulders. Let your shoulders drop and your gaze lower. If they tense, a few slow movements before you go on.
- Itching. First notice it for a few moments: sometimes it passes by itself. If not, scratch slowly, attending to the movement, and come back.
- Cold or heat. A blanket, or one layer less. It is part of being comfortable.
Attend to it, or move
A small discomfort can serve as an anchor for attention: where it is, how it changes, whether it moves or fades. Often you see that something that seemed fixed isn't. That is one way to practice, not an obligation.
But enduring is not the goal. If the discomfort grows or takes over your whole attention, move: adjust slowly, noticing the intention to move before you do it. Moving doesn't ruin the session.
When to stop
Stop if the pain is sharp, if it runs down an arm or a leg, if numbness doesn't go away when you move, if you feel dizzy, or if the pain builds instead of easing. That isn't ordinary sitting discomfort, and it isn't solved by enduring.
If you already have a condition in your back, knees, hips or joints, or an injury, ask a health professional which postures suit you. The U.S. National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) asks you to talk with your health care providers about any complementary approach you use, and not to use meditation to replace conventional care.
When the discomfort is of another kind
Sometimes what shows up when you sit still isn't a bodily ache but tension, a knot in the chest or an unease with no clear physical cause. Lindahl and colleagues (2017, PLOS ONE) interviewed practitioners and experts from Buddhist traditions and described difficult experiences in the body, among other areas, ranging from mild and passing to severe and lasting. If this happens often, you can stop, and with strong distress, talk to a health professional.
Common questions
My back hurts when I meditate: am I doing it wrong?
Not necessarily. It is often tension from straining to sit upright. Try the back of a chair, lengthen your spine without stiffness and change posture if you need to.
How do I keep my legs from falling asleep?
Change position, use a chair or a higher cushion, and stretch your legs when you finish. If the numbness doesn't go away, or happens often, check with a health professional.
Can I scratch during meditation?
Yes. Notice the itch for a few seconds and, if it stays, scratch slowly and come back. It isn't a failure.
When should I stop sitting?
If the pain is sharp, spreads to an arm or a leg, or gets worse. Try lying down or walking instead, and see a health professional if the pain persists.
Sources
- Ānāpānasati Sutta (MN 118), English translation by Thanissaro Bhikkhu, Access to Insight
- Satipaṭṭhāna Sutta (MN 10), English translation by Thanissaro Bhikkhu, Access to Insight
- NCCIH, U.S. National Institutes of Health: Meditation and Mindfulness, What You Need To Know
- Lindahl et al. (2017), The varieties of contemplative experience: A mixed-methods study of meditation-related challenges in Western Buddhists, PLOS ONE 12(5)