Meditate

Practical guide · 3 min read

Eyes open or closed

You can meditate with your eyes closed, open or somewhere between. There is no required way, and each changes the experience a little. With your eyes closed it is easier to turn inward; with them open it is easier to keep your attention alive. Here is what each is like, what a tradition that practices with open eyes teaches and how to choose.

The short answer

Pick whichever feels more comfortable today, and switch when you need to. Many people start with their eyes closed and open them when they get sleepy or their head fills with images. Others always practice with a lowered, soft gaze.

We found no studies comparing meditation with open and closed eyes, so there is no option the research backs over the other. The classic text on attention to the breath says nothing about eyes either: the Ānāpānasati Sutta (MN 118) describes the posture, legs crossed and body erect, and does not mention the gaze.

With your eyes closed

Closing them cuts down what comes in through sight and makes it easier to notice the breath, bodily sensations and thoughts. It is a widely used way, and guided meditations often say "if you like, close your eyes": an invitation, not an instruction.

It has its costs. With closed eyes sleep comes more easily, and sometimes the mind fills with images or memories. For some people it is uncomfortable, especially if what comes up is difficult. In that case, opening them is a simple and valid way out.

With your eyes open

In Zen, an open gaze is the tradition. Dōgen, a Japanese Zen master, wrote in his zazen instructions: "Keep your eyes open, but neither too widely nor too narrowly." According to an article from Antaiji monastery on Dōgen's Bendōhō, the reason given is practical: if you close them, you become sleepy. That source adds that Dōgen never uses the expression "half open," which is repeated so often.

In practice, the gaze drops about 45 degrees toward the floor, without focusing on anything in particular, and the eyes "see rather than look." Those lines are from that article, and this is a Zen teaching, not a general rule. For other traditions, and for someone meditating at home, it is one more option.

How to hold a soft gaze

  • Lower your eyes toward a point on the floor in front of you, or at the wall if you sit near one.
  • Let your eyelids relax, without forcing them up or down.
  • Do not look at the point: let it be there. If something moves, do not follow it.
  • Blink naturally. You do not have to hold out without blinking.
  • If your eyes tire or your vision blurs, close them for a moment and come back.

How to decide, and when to switch

  • If you often get sleepy, try your eyes open.
  • If your surroundings distract you, try your eyes closed, or a lowered, soft gaze.
  • If a strong feeling or a hard memory comes up, open your eyes and look around the room. It is a way to lean on the present, and there is an article on difficult feelings.
  • If you are in a guided meditation, follow the lines freely: they usually let you choose.
  • If you do not know, start each session with your eyes closed and open them if something changes. Or spend a week with each and compare how you feel.

A different thing: the fixed gaze

There are practices in which looking is the center, like contemplating a flame or a point. That is not the same as the soft gaze of Zen: here the eyes rest on something with intention. If you are curious, there is a guided meditation of that kind. If you have any condition of the eyes or vision, check with a health professional first.

Common questions

Is meditating with closed eyes better?

No studies settle it. Closing them helps you turn inward, but makes sleep more likely. Try both and choose by the day.

Can I keep them open without getting distracted?

Yes, with a lowered, soft gaze that does not fix on anything. If you do get distracted, close them for a bit.

What if closing my eyes makes me uncomfortable?

Open them and let your gaze rest softly on a spot on the floor. You do not have to close them for it to count as meditation.

Are open eyes only a Zen thing?

It is the traditional way in Sōtō Zen, but anyone can use it. Many people meditate with their eyes closed, and both ways are valid.

Sources

To practice

Keep reading