What the research says about timing
None of the sources I checked compares morning meditation with evening meditation. What has been studied is how much people practice. Parsons and colleagues (2017, Behaviour Research and Therapy) pooled 43 studies of eight-week programs, with 1,427 participants. On average, people did about 64% of the home practice they were asked to do, around 30 minutes a day, six days a week.
In 28 of those studies, with 898 participants, more home practice was linked, by a small margin, with better results. That is an association, not proof: people who feel better may simply practice more. And it is about amount, not time of day.
In the morning
The upside: the day hasn't filled up yet, there is less noise, and it is easy to attach the practice to something you already do, like coffee or brushing your teeth. If you leave it for "later," it tends to go undone.
The catch: when you wake up your body is stiff, and sitting still can be hard. If sleep wins, wash your face, open your eyes or start with a walking practice. And if your mornings are a scramble, five minutes may be more realistic than twenty.
At night
The upside: it works as a closing. You can put the day down instead of dragging it into bed, and you don't have to get up afterward. Some meditations are made for this, with long silences and few instructions.
The catch: sleep. If you doze off halfway, that isn't a failure, but then the practice is working as a sleep aid and not as a stretch of attention. Also, with your head full of the day, it can be harder to come back to your anchor. A guided meditation or counting exhales can help.
And in between
Many people find their slot midmorning, before lunch or when they get home. Three minutes before a meeting or after a hard day counts too. What works against you is a time that changes every day: it is hard for that to become a habit.
A one-week experiment
- Days 1 to 3. Meditate five minutes in the morning, at the same time.
- Days 4 to 6. Meditate five minutes at night, at the same time.
- Day 7. Write in your diary how you felt before and after each one, and which was easier to keep.
- Choose the one you kept with the least effort, not the one that sounds best. In a month you can test again.
Common questions
Is it better to meditate on an empty stomach?
I found no studies supporting that. Some people prefer to do it before eating, for comfort. Listen to your body.
Can I meditate twice a day?
Yes, if it fits. No figure is backed by studies. Starting with one steady session is usually more sustainable.
Will meditating at night keep me awake?
For most gentle practices there is no reason to expect it, but people react differently. If a meditation wakes you up, move it to another time of day.
Does it matter if I always meditate at the same time?
A fixed time has no demonstrated effect in itself. What programs show is that regular practice is linked, by a small margin, with better results, and a fixed time helps you remember it.
Sources
- Parsons et al. (2017), Home practice in Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy and Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction, Behaviour Research and Therapy 95
- Carmody and Baer (2008), Relationships between mindfulness practice and levels of mindfulness, medical and psychological symptoms and well-being in a mindfulness-based stress reduction program, Journal of Behavioral Medicine 31(1)
- NCCIH, U.S. National Institutes of Health: Meditation and Mindfulness, What You Need To Know