What you do in a sleep meditation
Usually it is a gentle kind of attention: moving through the body one part at a time, following the air in and out, or letting a memory of the day pass without staying with it. A voice, if there is one, says little and leaves long silences.
What sets it apart is the intention. You are not trying to stay awake: if sleep comes, the practice did its job. In a meditation for focus, drifting off counts as an obstacle. At night, it doesn't.
What the trials found
Black and colleagues (2015, JAMA Internal Medicine) randomly assigned 49 older adults, average age 66 and with moderate sleep problems, to a mindfulness program or to a sleep hygiene education program. Both ran six weeks, with two hours of class a week plus homework. At the end, the mindfulness group had improved more in sleep quality, by a difference of 1.8 points on a sleep quality scale. It also improved more in insomnia symptoms, depression symptoms and fatigue. The authors call it a short-term benefit.
The National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) sums up the wider picture this way: a 2019 analysis found mindfulness improved sleep more than education-based treatments, but no more than cognitive behavioral therapy or exercise.
What they did not find
Black's study had 49 participants, all older, and one comparison. It doesn't say how long the effect lasts, or whether a single twenty-minute meditation at bedtime does what a six-week program with a teacher does. The programs studied are a different thing from playing a track at night.
The 2014 review by Goyal and colleagues (JAMA Internal Medicine), with 47 trials and 3,515 participants, found low evidence of no effect on sleep, or insufficient evidence of any effect. In other words, across that body of studies, sleep was not where results showed up best.
There is work on yoga nidra and other guided relaxation for sleep, but it is small and scarce, and I don't use it here as proof of anything.
How to try it, realistically
- Pick one practice for a week or two: a body scan, or a meditation about letting the day go. Switching every night makes it hard to tell what helps.
- Put it at the same time, after screens are off, as a way to close the day and not another task.
- Let sleep win. If you miss the ending, nothing was lost. You don't have to finish it.
- Keep the volume low and use a timer. A long track doesn't need to play all night.
- If sleep doesn't come, don't fight it. Lying awake with a still body is also rest. Checking the clock usually makes the wait worse.
When sleep is a real problem
A bad week is one thing; hard nights for months are another. If you struggle to sleep most nights, wake up anxious, or find that tiredness is affecting your days, talk to a health professional. Meditation can sit alongside treatment, but it doesn't replace it.
And if being still in the dark brings up thoughts or memories that weigh on you, open your eyes, turn on a soft light and leave the practice for another time. Stopping is a valid choice.
Common questions
Does meditation help you sleep better?
Some trials find better sleep quality, mostly against education programs. A large review found low or insufficient evidence of an effect on sleep. You can try it without expecting a result.
Is it bad to fall asleep during a meditation?
Not if the meditation is for sleep. That is the point. If you meditate in the daytime to focus, falling asleep is a sign to change your posture or the time of day.
How long before bed should I meditate?
No figure is backed by studies. Many people do it in bed, at the end of the day, and let it fade out on its own.
What if I wake up in the middle of the night?
You can repeat a short meditation or move slowly through your body, without checking the time. If it happens often, mention it to a health professional.
Sources
- Black et al. (2015), Mindfulness meditation and improvement in sleep quality and daytime impairment among older adults with sleep disturbances, JAMA Internal Medicine 175(4)
- Goyal et al. (2014), Meditation programs for psychological stress and well-being, JAMA Internal Medicine 174(3)
- NCCIH, U.S. National Institutes of Health: Meditation and Mindfulness, What You Need To Know