Meditate

Background · 3 min read

Meditating with apps: what the studies show

Meditating with an app or a website is now the most common way to start. There are trials on this, and they show small effects on some measures, with many limits. They also show something you can see in real life: most people stop using apps soon. Here is what was measured, with figures, and what is worth keeping in mind. I do not compare or recommend any.

What is being studied

The studies do not evaluate "apps" in general. They evaluate specific mindfulness programs and compare people who use them with people who do not, or who do something else. That is why an average figure blends very different apps, durations and comparison groups.

What the meta-analyses found

In 2021, Gál, Ștefan and Cristea pooled 34 randomized trials in the Journal of Affective Disorders, with 7,566 participants, in which a meditation app was the main intervention. After the program there were small to moderate effects on perceived stress (g = 0.46), anxiety (0.28), depression (0.33) and psychological well-being (0.29). They were not significant for distress (0.10) or general well-being (0.14). The authors call the results "promising," and warn of few studies, uncertain risk of bias and large differences among them.

In 2024, Linardon and colleagues updated the analysis with 45 trials. The effect was small: g = 0.24 for depression and 0.28 for anxiety against comparison groups. Against active therapeutic comparisons the effects were not significant, though there were few studies. They conclude that apps can reduce symptoms in the short term, and that higher-quality studies with longer follow-up are needed.

Notice the direction: as the analysis widens and quality is demanded, the numbers tend to drop. Any figure from a single study is provisional.

The dropout problem

In 2020, Torous and colleagues reviewed 18 trials of apps for depressive symptoms (not only meditation), with 3,336 randomized participants. Pooled dropout was 26.2 percent, rising to 47.8 percent when adjusted for publication bias. It was lower in studies with human feedback or in-app mood monitoring.

Outside trials, the picture is harsher. Baumel and colleagues (2019) analyzed usage data from 93 Android mental health apps with more than 10,000 installs. The median share of people opening them each day was 4.0 percent, and median retention was 3.9 percent at 15 days and 3.3 percent at 30 days. For meditation apps, 30-day retention was 4.7 percent, and active users spent a median of about 21 minutes a day.

The two sets of figures are not comparable: one comes from people inside a study, with follow-up, the other from real-world use. Baumel measured use, not health outcomes.

What is not known

None of the studies I cite shows that one app is better than another, and here I compare and recommend none. How long an effect lasts is also not well known: follow-ups are short. The U.S. National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) notes in general that much mindfulness research has short follow-up and that study quality is a concern.

What to look at before using one

  • What it asks of you. A sign-up, an account, your data? Check what it keeps and where.
  • Whether there are ads or subscriptions that interrupt practice.
  • What it claims. Be wary of phrases like "reduces anxiety" or "rewires your brain."
  • Whether it lets you start small. Five minutes, kept up, are worth more than a big plan you drop.
  • What you do when you feel distress. An app does not replace a mental health professional.

Common questions

Do meditation apps work?

Meta-analyses find small to moderate effects on stress, anxiety and depression compared with doing nothing. Against other active comparisons they are not significant, and study quality is uneven.

Why do most people stop using them?

The data show very few people still using an app weeks after installing it. The studies do not explain why, but it is common: losing the habit is not a personal failing.

Is an app better than a course with a teacher?

The studies reviewed do not compare them. An in-person course offers conversation and company, and an app offers convenience. Choose what you can keep up.

Can I meditate without an app?

Yes. You can sit down, set a timer on your phone, or simply attend to your breath for a few minutes.

Sources

To practice

Keep reading