Three different things under one word
People talk about "sound for meditation" as if it were one thing. There are really three: music or soundscapes (rain, water, a continuous drone), bowls and bells played live, and binaural beats, which means hearing a slightly different tone in each ear through headphones. The difference between the two tones is perceived as a pulse.
Each has its own research, with little in common among them. And almost none studied what happens when someone meditates with that sound, which is what you would want to know.
Music: the biggest study, but about stress in general
In 2020, de Witte and colleagues published two meta-analyses in Health Psychology Review covering 104 randomized trials, 327 effect sizes and 9,617 participants. Music interventions reduced stress: an effect of d = 0.380 on physiological measures and d = 0.545 on psychological ones. Among the physiological ones, heart rate showed the largest effect (0.456), ahead of hormones (0.349) and blood pressure (0.343).
These are small to moderate effects. But there is an important limit: these are music interventions in general, mostly listening to chosen or prescribed music in stressful situations, not meditation. It says nothing about whether music plus meditation adds anything.
Binaural beats: results that shift with the details
In 2019, Garcia-Argibay, Santed and Reales pooled 22 studies (35 effect sizes) on binaural beats in Psychological Research and found a medium overall effect, g = 0.45, across memory, attention, anxiety and pain. But the effect depended on the frequency, the exposure time and when the tone was heard. It is a blend of different outcomes, and it does not isolate relaxation or sleep.
In 2023, Basu and Banerjee analyzed 15 studies on memory and attention and found g = 0.40, but they describe mixed results, especially for theta and beta frequencies, and call for more rigorous studies. In other words: there are signals, not a firm conclusion. And none of this work shows that binaural beats help you meditate better.
Singing bowls: one observational study
Goldsby and colleagues (2017) studied 62 people, mean age 49.7, in bowl sound meditation sessions. After a session they reported less tension, anger, fatigue and depressed mood, and more spiritual well-being. People new to the practice had a bigger drop in tension than experienced ones.
It is an observational study: people were asked before and after, with no comparison group and no random assignment. It shows that people felt different, not that the bowl was the cause. Someone who comes to a quiet session, lying down, with other people, is already changing pace for those reasons.
What I do not know, and nobody seems to
I did not find a trial comparing guided, silent and music-backed meditation for results or for sticking with it. Nor is there evidence on synthesized sounds like those Meditate uses (a drone, rain, the sea or brown noise). When someone says one sound "works better," they are usually describing their own experience, and that counts as experience.
How to choose
- Try and compare. One session in silence, another with background sound. Notice which makes it easier to come back to attention.
- If the sound distracts you, remove it. Silence is a complete option too.
- With headphones and binaural beats, watch the volume, and do not use them while driving or doing anything that needs your attention.
- Be wary of promises: "synchronize your brain waves" or "balance your energy" are not sentences these studies allow.
Common questions
Do binaural beats work?
Meta-analyses find medium effects overall, but with mixed results by frequency and task, and with small studies. There is no firm proof, and none of them studies meditation itself.
Does music help you meditate?
Music lowers stress measures in many trials, but those studies are not about meditation. If it helps you stay, use it. If it distracts you, try without it.
Do singing bowls have proven effects?
One observational study of 62 people found less tension after a session. With no comparison group, it cannot tell whether the bowl was the cause.
Is it better to meditate with sound or in silence?
No studies compare them well. It depends on the person and the day, and you can alternate.
Sources
- de Witte et al. (2020), Effects of music interventions on stress-related outcomes, Health Psychology Review 14(2)
- Garcia-Argibay, Santed and Reales (2019), Efficacy of binaural auditory beats in cognition, anxiety, and pain perception, Psychological Research 83(2)
- Basu and Banerjee (2023), Potential of binaural beats intervention for improving memory and attention, Psychological Research 87(4)
- Goldsby et al. (2017), Effects of singing bowl sound meditation on mood, tension, and well-being: an observational study, Journal of Evidence-Based Complementary & Alternative Medicine 22(3)