Meditate

Heart

Loving-kindness meditation for a difficult person

After wishing yourself well and wishing well to someone you love, you take a small step: the same phrases for a person you find difficult. It is not approving of what they do, and it is not making up. You start with someone who only bothers you a little, and you can come back to yourself at any moment. It takes ten, fifteen or twenty minutes.

10 min15 min20 min

Getting ready

  1. Choose the person before you start: someone who irritates you or makes you a little uncomfortable, not the person who hurt you most.
  2. Sit on a chair, a cushion or the edge of your bed, with your back upright and your shoulders loose. Close your eyes or lower your gaze.
  3. The voice starts with you and with someone you love, and only then moves to the difficult person. If it gets to be too much at any point, go back to either of the first two.
  4. If anger comes up, you can open your eyes, move or stop. There is nothing to prove.
  5. At the end, the voice brings you back to yourself and a bell rings.

The full script

This is what you will hear. Between one line and the next there are silences; they are part of the practice.

Sit in a steady way, with your back upright and your shoulders loose. Close your eyes if you like. Or lower your gaze to one still spot. Feel where your body is supported, and let your hands rest. Notice that you are breathing, without changing anything. Before thinking of anyone, start with yourself. Say it silently, slowly. May I be safe. May I be at peace. Now think of someone you love and wish them the same. May you be safe. May you be at peace. This practice has one more step, and it is a tender one. You can stay with either of the first two. Choose someone you find a little difficult. A small irritation, not a wound. Someone at work, someone in your building, a person who annoys you without having harmed you. Do not choose the person who hurt you most. They are not for today. Wishing them well is not approving of what they do, or making up, or giving up your limits. Bring this person to mind, without bringing them too close. They can stay far off, at the edge of the picture. Like you, this person wants to be well, even if they go about it in ways that bother you. Listen to the phrases once, for them. May you be safe. May you be at peace. May you be kind to yourself. May you live with ease. Now say them yourself, silently, at your own pace. Even without much conviction.

Anger, pushback or a memory of what bothered you may come up. That is normal. You do not have to fight it. If the anger grows, go back to yourself or to the person you love, and stay there a while. Going back is always allowed.

When it settles, if you like, return to the difficult person.

If it helps, recall something small and good about them. A gesture, a word, a moment.

If you find nothing, that is fine too. It is enough to know they want to be well, like you.

If anything becomes too much, stop. Open your eyes, move, look around. There is nothing to prove. Keep going with the phrases on your own. May you be safe. May you be at peace.

May you be kind to yourself. May you live with ease.

If your mind wandered, or started arguing with them, that is what minds do. Come back to the phrase.

You can take turns. One round of phrases for yourself, one for the difficult person.

The phrases may sound false. Say them anyway, as an experiment. Saying them is the practice.

Keep going on your own, at a pace you can sustain.

Now let this person go and notice how your body is. Your jaw, your shoulders, your chest.

To close, come back to yourself. May I be safe. May I be at peace.

Let the phrases go. Notice your breathing and the weight of your body. Listen to the sounds around you. Slowly move your fingers and shoulders. When you are ready, open your eyes. That is all. A small step counts, and you can take it again another day.

What it is

This is loving-kindness meditation, or metta, aimed at someone you find hard. You silently repeat the same four phrases as in the other kindness meditations: may you be safe, may you be at peace, may you be kind to yourself, may you live with ease. What changes is who you say them to.

Wishing someone well is not approving of what they do. It does not mean forgiving, making up, giving up your limits or seeing them again. You can keep every decision you have made about the relationship and still practice, for a few minutes, not feeding the anger.

That is why the session starts with you and with someone you love, and reminds you more than once that you can go back there. You practice with a small irritation, not a deep wound.

Where it comes from

In the Visuddhimagga, the manual Buddhaghosa wrote in Sri Lanka around the fifth century, the hostile person comes last. After oneself and a very dear friend, the text asks you to regard a neutral person as dear and, finally, the hostile person as neutral. It does not ask you to love them. It asks that they stop being an enemy in your mind.

The same text says not to begin with the hostile person, because remembering them stirs up anger. And if anger does arise, the instruction is to go back again and again to the earlier people, and only then turn once more to the difficult one. This meditation follows that advice: going back to yourself or to someone you love is always allowed.

To let go of resentment, the manual suggests, among other things, noticing something good about the person, even a single gesture, and considering the harm your own anger does to you.

What people use it for

Many people use it when they notice someone takes up more room in their head than they would like: a coworker, a relative with whom everything is tense, a neighbor. It does not change that person. What you practice is a different way of carrying them around inside.

Others do it after a run-in, once the worst has passed, so they do not keep replaying the argument. If the anger is still very fresh, the meditation for after an argument is usually a better first step.

What studies say

There are no studies of this stage on its own. The review by Galante and colleagues, published in 2014 in the Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, pooled 22 randomized trials of kindness and compassion meditations. Compared with no intervention, it found a moderate increase in compassion, measured by questionnaire. Compared with other activities, results were inconclusive, and the studies were small and of low to moderate quality.

A meta-analysis by Kreplin, Farias and Brazil, published in 2018 in Scientific Reports, reviewed randomized trials of meditation and behavior toward others. It found effects on compassion and empathy, but not on aggression or prejudice. And the rise in compassion appeared only when the meditation teacher was also an author of the study and when the comparison group was a waitlist. The authors conclude that popular beliefs about these effects are overstated.

What you may notice

Most likely, anger or pushback will show up, or a voice saying this person does not deserve it. That is to be expected, not a failure. You can notice where you feel it in your body, in your jaw, your shoulders or your chest, and go back to the phrase or to yourself.

It is also common for the mind to start arguing with this person or replaying what happened. When you notice it, come back to the phrase.

If thinking of this person brings fear, memories that flood in, or strong physical distress, stop. You chose someone too difficult for today, and that says nothing bad about you.

Which length to choose

In ten minutes the voice is with you almost the whole time, and the step toward the difficult person is short. In fifteen and twenty, the silent stretches with the phrases are longer, and you can move between yourself and that person at your own pace.

Start with ten, after you have done kindness toward yourself and toward someone you love at least once. Go longer only when the irritation you chose feels manageable.

Common mistakes

  • Starting with the person who hurt you most. Start with a small irritation.
  • Thinking that wishing them well means agreeing with them. Your limits still stand.
  • Forcing yourself to feel warmth. Saying the phrases is enough, even if they sound false.
  • Holding on through the anger so as not to interrupt. Going back to yourself is part of the practice.
  • Using the session to rehearse what you will say to them. If that happens, come back to the phrase.

Keep in mind

  • Do not choose someone who seriously harmed you, abused you or frightens you. This practice is not for that, and it does not replace help from a professional.
  • If intrusive memories, panic or strong distress come up, stop. Open your eyes, move, and turn to something that makes you feel safe.
  • If you live with trauma, especially trauma involving another person, talk to a mental health professional first.

Common questions

Does wishing a difficult person well mean forgiving them?

No. The phrases are a wish you say silently, not a decision about the relationship. You can practice and still keep your limits, never see that person again, or not forgive what happened.

Who should I choose for loving-kindness toward a difficult person?

Someone who bothers you a little: a person at work, someone who lives nearby, an acquaintance who gets on your nerves. Never the person who hurt you most, especially at the start. Over time you can move on to somewhat bigger irritations, if you want.

What if I get really angry?

Go back to yourself or to the person you love and repeat the phrases there until it eases. That is the instruction in the classic manual for this practice. If the anger does not ease, stop: you can try another day with someone else.

Can it fix a relationship?

No study shows that. What has been measured are changes in the person meditating, such as compassion, and the results are modest. What you do about the relationship is a separate decision, one you can make with a calmer head.

Sources