What it is and where it comes from
In the oldest Buddhist texts, loving-kindness is mettā (Pali): goodwill, the wish that others be well. The Access to Insight glossary defines it as "loving-kindness; goodwill." It is one of the four "sublime abodes," or brahmavihāra, along with compassion (karuṇā), appreciative joy (muditā) and equanimity (upekkhā).
The best-known text on the subject is the Karaṇīya Mettā Sutta (Sn 1.8, also Khp 9). In Piyadassi Thera's translation it asks you to cultivate "a boundless love towards all beings." The introduction to that edition says the Buddha taught it to a group of monks spending the rainy season in a forest. As with any tradition, what is practiced today in a room or on a phone is an adaptation of that, and it varies by school.
How it is practiced
You usually begin with yourself, then move to someone dear, someone neutral, someone you have tension with and, finally, all beings. At each step you silently repeat short phrases of good will. You do not have to feel anything special: the practice is directing attention and phrases, and noticing what comes up, even if it is coldness or resistance.
What one trial with working adults found
In 2008, Fredrickson and colleagues published a field experiment in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology with 139 working adults. Half were randomly assigned to begin loving-kindness practice. According to the abstract, the practice increased daily positive emotions over time, and those emotions were linked to more personal resources (mindfulness, a sense of purpose, social support, fewer physical symptoms). Those resources predicted greater life satisfaction and fewer depressive symptoms.
It is a single study with a particular sample, and I read only its abstract. It shows an association along a process, not that the practice works the same way for everyone.
What the reviews found
In 2014, Galante and colleagues reviewed 22 randomized trials of kindness-based meditation (loving-kindness and compassion practices) in the Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology. Against passive control groups, who did nothing, they found a moderate effect on self-reported depression and increases in mindfulness, compassion and self-compassion. Against progressive relaxation there were more positive emotions. For other outcomes, especially against active comparison groups, results were inconclusive.
The authors themselves rate study quality as low to moderate, and note wide confidence intervals because the studies were small. They also note that some people may find the practice challenging at first.
In 2018, Kreplin, Farias and Brazil reviewed randomized trials of meditation in healthy adults and prosocial behavior in Scientific Reports. They found a moderate overall increase, but it depended on the kind of behavior and on study quality. There was an effect on compassion and empathy, and none on aggression, feelings of connectedness or prejudice. And one detail worth remembering: the gain in compassion appeared only when the meditation teacher was a co-author of the study and when the comparison group was a wait list rather than an activity.
Why to read it with care
- Comparing with "nothing" favors the practice. When the comparison is another activity, effects shrink or disappear.
- Who runs the study matters. That a result depends on whether the teacher is a co-author does not prove bad faith, but it calls for caution.
- Many measures are questionnaires. People who practice know they are practicing.
- Few studies measure real behavior. Feeling more compassionate and acting more compassionately are not the same thing.
- I have not confirmed figures on self-compassion. Specific meta-analyses exist, but I could not open them, so I do not cite them.
What you can honestly say
There are signs that the practice is linked to more positive emotions and somewhat fewer depressive symptoms, in small studies with a lot of variation. There is no basis for saying it makes someone kinder in daily life, or that it replaces therapy.
If it is hard to wish yourself well, or sadness or anger shows up, that is an experience people often describe. You can change the phrase, stop, or leave it for another day. If it is intense, it is worth talking to a mental health professional.
Common questions
Is loving-kindness meditation scientifically proven?
There are trials and reviews, and they show small to moderate effects on some measures, mostly against doing nothing. Against comparison activities results are less clear, and study quality is low to moderate.
Is it a religious practice?
It began within Buddhism and appears in texts such as the Karaṇīya Mettā Sutta. Today it is also taught outside religious settings. You can practice it without believing anything in particular, knowing where it comes from.
What if I feel nothing, or feel resistance?
You do not need to feel anything special. Repeat the phrases calmly, notice what is there and come back to them. If it is too much, start with someone easy to care about, or switch to another practice.
Does it help with depression?
Some studies observed fewer self-reported depressive symptoms. It is not a treatment. If you have depression, talk to a health professional.
Sources
- Fredrickson et al. (2008), Open hearts build lives, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 95(5)
- Galante et al. (2014), Effect of kindness-based meditation on health and well-being, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 82(6)
- Kreplin, Farias and Brazil (2018), The limited prosocial effects of meditation, Scientific Reports 8
- Access to Insight: Karaṇīya Mettā Sutta, Sn 1.8, translated by Piyadassi Thera
- Access to Insight: glossary (mettā, brahma-vihāra)