What a retreat is
Typically you leave your routine for a few days and practice several hours a day, in a place set apart. There are one-day and weekend retreats, and some last weeks. Some are silent and others include conversation; some follow a specific tradition and others are secular. Each organizer sets its own rules, which is why it matters to read them first.
A retreat is closer to an immersion than to a longer session. With time and no screens, what you cover with noise at home tends to surface: boredom, tiredness, memories.
One example: the ten-day course
The vipassana courses offered through dhamma.org are a well-known example. According to their code of discipline, the ten-day course actually spans twelve days, counting arrival and departure. The day starts with a bell at 4:00 a.m., includes a talk by the teacher from 7:00 to 8:15 p.m., and lights go out at 9:30 p.m.
Students keep what they call "Noble Silence": silence of body, speech and mind, though they may speak with the teacher and the management. Mobile phones and other devices are handed in until the end. Reading, writing and music are out. Everyone commits to five precepts, which include no killing, stealing, lying, sexual activity or intoxicants.
These courses run on donations: according to the same code, donations are accepted only from people who have completed a ten-day course, and the teachers and organizers are not paid. Other retreats work differently, so ask how they are funded.
What the studies say
Khoury and colleagues (2017, Journal of Psychosomatic Research) reviewed 21 studies with 2,912 participants in traditional retreats. They found moderate effects on anxiety, depression, stress, mindfulness and compassion, which held at follow-up. They concluded that retreats are moderately to largely effective at reducing depression, anxiety and stress.
Read that within limits. The studies differed a lot in design, length and measures, and they reflect people who chose to go. They don't tell you how it would go for you. Nor are they a study of risks: the NCCIH, the U.S. government's center for complementary health, notes that harmful effects of meditation have been little studied, and cites a 2020 review in which about 8 percent of participants had a negative effect, most often anxiety and depression.
Who should think twice
An intensive retreat, with hours of silence and little to distract you, can stir things up. Lindahl and colleagues (2017, PLOS ONE) described difficult meditation experiences ranging from mild and passing to severe and lasting. The dhamma.org code itself says they do not recommend their course for people with significant mental health issues, and that old symptoms may resurface during or after a course.
If you live with trauma, depression, strong anxiety, a recent loss or take medication, talk first with your mental health professional or doctor. If something like that weighs on you during a short practice at home, that is a good reason to go gently. A retreat doesn't replace treatment, and shorter retreats are a way to try.
How to judge an organizer
- Rules written down before you go: schedule, silence, devices, meals, what is expected of you.
- Who teaches, and with what training. The NCCIH recommends asking about the training and experience of whoever guides.
- How difficulties are handled. Whether there is someone to talk to during the retreat, and what happens if you feel unwell.
- Whether you can leave. A good organizer explains how to do it without pressure or guilt.
- What they ask about health. A health form and a question about your medication are a good sign.
- What it costs and how it is funded, stated plainly, with no promises of transformation.
Common questions
Do I need experience to go on a retreat?
It depends on the retreat. Some welcome beginners and others require previous practice. Read what each one asks, and if you're unsure, try a short one first.
How much does a retreat cost?
It varies a lot. Some run on donations, like the dhamma.org courses, where only people who have completed a course can donate. Others set a price. Ask how it is funded.
Can a silent retreat be dangerous?
For most people it is hard but safe, but risks are little studied: anxiety or depression can appear. If you have a mental health history, talk to your professional first.
Can I leave if I don't feel well?
Ask beforehand. In the dhamma.org course, students commit to staying for the whole course. Choose organizers who explain how to leave.
Sources
- Dhamma.org, Code of Discipline for vipassana courses
- Khoury et al. (2017), Effectiveness of traditional meditation retreats: A systematic review and meta-analysis, Journal of Psychosomatic Research 92
- Lindahl et al. (2017), The varieties of contemplative experience: A mixed-methods study of meditation-related challenges in Western Buddhists, PLOS ONE 12(5)
- NCCIH, U.S. National Institutes of Health: Meditation and Mindfulness, What You Need To Know