Meditate

Background · 3 min read

How meditation came to the West

Meditation did not reach the West at one moment or through one door. It came in waves: lectures, books, teachers who traveled, retreats and, finally, hospital programs. Here are some dates I could confirm, who stands behind them, and what the sources tell differently.

Before the dates: a warning

It helps to say what this story is not. There was contemplation in the West long before (the Christian tradition has its own), and the practices that came from Asia were already, there, very different traditions. I follow only the path of practices of Indian, Buddhist and Zen origin toward Europe and America from the nineteenth century on. It is a selection, not a full account.

1881 and 1893: a word and a stage

In 1881 the scholar T. W. Rhys Davids first translated the Pali term sati as "mindfulness," as Rupert Gethin recounts in a 2011 article. That English word is the one now used around the world, with meanings that are no longer exactly those of the old text.

The World's Parliament of Religions opened on September 11, 1893, in Chicago, in the building that is now the Art Institute, and ran until September 27. Swami Vivekananda spoke on the first day, representing Hinduism. His speech is remembered as a key moment in the presentation of Indian ideas to an American audience.

D. T. Suzuki and Zen

The Japanese scholar D. T. Suzuki (1870 to 1966) published the first series of his Essays in Zen Buddhism in English in 1927. From 1949 he lectured at Columbia University, and in 1951 he toured American universities. In 1957 he was profiled in major magazines and became widely known.

His influence was huge, and so is the criticism. David McMahan (2008) argues that Suzuki lifted Zen texts out of their social and ritual setting and presented them in the philosophical vocabulary of the West. There are further objections about his relation to Japanese nationalism, and scholars who qualify them. It illustrates something general: what reached the West was also a version of the practices, not only the practices.

Transcendental Meditation and the sixties

Maharishi Mahesh Yogi began teaching publicly in India in 1955, and his first world tour began in 1959. The technique was first called "Transcendental Deep Meditation" and later Transcendental Meditation, which is now a registered name. In February 1968 the Beatles traveled to his center in Rishikesh, India, to study with him. The visit of so famous a group made the subject very visible.

The sources I read do not agree on every detail of how long each member stayed, and accounts of how that chapter ended differ.

Retreats: 1975 and 1976

The Insight Meditation Society, in Barre, Massachusetts, is a retreat center for insight meditation. Its own page says that in 1975 a group of young teachers, among them Joseph Goldstein, Sharon Salzberg and Jack Kornfield, decided to create it, and that it opened its doors on February 14, 1976. That is why you will see 1975 in some places and 1976 in others: one is the decision, the other the opening.

Hospitals: 1979 and 1982

Jon Kabat-Zinn created mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR) in 1979 at the University of Massachusetts medical center, according to the center's own page. His first paper on the program appeared in 1982 in General Hospital Psychiatry: 51 people with chronic pain, a ten-week program, no comparison group. About half had a reduction of at least 50 percent on a pain rating scale, and the author notes the study was uncontrolled. That is why some texts say 1979 and others 1982: one is the program, the other the first published study.

From there research grew a great deal. What it shows, and what it does not, is in the article on what science says.

What the dates leave out

A timeline makes something scattered look orderly. Many people learned to meditate from books, friends or yoga classes, leaving no trace on any list. And not everything that came West keeps the way it was practiced at its source. Knowing where a practice comes from helps you use it more clearly, without claiming it as your own.

Common questions

Who brought meditation to the West?

No single person did. Among others: Swami Vivekananda in 1893, D. T. Suzuki through his books from 1927, Maharishi Mahesh Yogi from the late 1950s, and the teachers who opened retreat centers in the seventies.

When did mindfulness begin in medicine?

Jon Kabat-Zinn created the MBSR program in 1979 at the University of Massachusetts and published his first study in 1982. Sources use one date or the other depending on whether they mean the program or the paper.

Did the Beatles popularize meditation?

Their trip to Rishikesh in February 1968 made it very visible in popular culture. That is not the whole story: there had been teachers and books for decades.

Is Transcendental Meditation the same as meditating?

It is one specific technique, and its name is registered. Meditation is a much broader term. It is mentioned here only as a historical fact.

Sources

To practice

Keep reading