Where the practices come from
The U.S. National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) says many meditative techniques began in Eastern traditions and have a history going back thousands of years. Studies that describe meditation experiences often involve people from specific traditions: Lindahl and colleagues' 2017 research, for example, interviewed practitioners and experts from the Theravada, Zen and Tibetan traditions.
That includes practices with a clear devotional background. Loving-kindness, for example, appears in Buddhist texts as a path toward calm; and Transcendental Meditation, whose name is registered, is taught with its own technique and method. If a practice comes with rituals, chants or ideas about the world, it is reasonable to ask whether they sit well with you.
What changed when it left the temples
In 1979, Jon Kabat-Zinn developed mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR) at a University of Massachusetts medical center. It was a course for patients inside a hospital, with meditation, body exercises and conversation. Since then it has been taught in many other places.
But the origin did not disappear. In 2011 the scholar Rupert Gethin recalled that the word "mindfulness" is a translation of the Pali term sati, proposed in 1881 by T. W. Rhys Davids. He explains that the definition that shaped MBSR and mindfulness-based cognitive therapy comes from a Buddhist teacher (Nyanaponika), that some aspects of the traditional definition are missing from the clinical version, and that the idea of "non-judging" deserves a closer look from a Buddhist point of view. He also concludes that these differences may matter less in clinical practice.
What can be said in each direction
- "It is not religious" is partly true. You can practice attention to the breath without believing anything, and many people do.
- "It is religious" is also partly true. The origins, the texts and many teachers are Buddhist, Hindu or from other traditions, and some practices carry content that is not neutral.
- "It is a neutral technique" is a simplification. Every practice brings assumptions about what attention, suffering or the self is.
- "It is incompatible with my faith" is not a rule either. Some religious people meditate and see it as support for their faith, and others prefer not to. It is your decision.
How to decide if it fits
Ask where what you are about to do comes from and what it asks of you. A meditation of attention to the breath, or to sounds, only asks you to attend. One with phrases of good wishes for other people asks for something closer to an attitude. One with mantras, images or particular texts may carry a religious meaning for those who created it.
You can keep what serves you and leave the rest. You can also leave meditation entirely: nothing obliges you.
One thing to keep in mind
That a practice is taught without religion does not make it a treatment: NCCIH advises against using it to replace health care or to delay seeing a provider.
Common questions
Can I meditate if I am religious?
Yes, many people do. Some see it as a complement to their faith and others prefer not to mix them. If a practice creates conflict for you, you can choose another or drop it.
Is meditation Buddhism?
Not necessarily. Many techniques began in Buddhism, Hinduism and other traditions, but they are now also taught outside them. Knowing the origin helps you use them with respect.
Is mindfulness the same as Buddhist meditation?
The term comes from a translation of a Buddhist concept, and clinical programs drew on it. Scholars point out differences between the clinical version and the traditional one.
Do I have to believe in something for it to work?
No belief is needed to pay attention to your breath. What studies observe are programs, not beliefs, and they do not promise results.
Sources
- NCCIH, U.S. National Institutes of Health: Meditation and Mindfulness, What You Need To Know
- Gethin, R. (2011), On some definitions of mindfulness, Contemporary Buddhism 12(1)
- UMass Memorial Health, Center for Mindfulness
- Lindahl et al. (2017), The varieties of contemplative experience, PLoS One 12(5)
- Access to Insight: Karaṇīya Mettā Sutta, Sn 1.8