Meditate

Imagery

Lake meditation

You picture a lake and let your body become that lake: the breath and your thoughts stir the surface, and further down the water stays still. You can do it sitting or lying on your back, and it takes ten, fifteen or twenty minutes.

10 min15 min20 min

Getting ready

  1. Choose whether to sit or lie down. If you sit, use a chair or a cushion, with your back long. If you lie down, lie on your back with your arms by your sides.
  2. If you lie down, you can put a cushion under your knees and a blanket over you.
  3. Close your eyes or rest your gaze on one spot. If you get very sleepy, open them a little.
  4. If you need to move, do it slowly and come back to the image of the water.
  5. A bowl rings at the end. If you are on your back, roll onto one side before you sit up.

The full script

This is what you will hear. Between one line and the next there are silences; they are part of the practice.

You can do this practice sitting or lying on your back. Choose a way you can hold for a while. Close your eyes if you like. Or let your gaze rest on one spot. Feel the weight of your body and the places where it rests. Notice that you are breathing. Change nothing. Feel the air coming in and the air going out. In this practice you picture a lake. One you know, one you saw once, or one you make up now. You do not need to see it sharply. It is enough to know it is there. Picture the water in a hollow of the earth. The earth holds it from below and from the sides. Notice the shore. Stones, sand, reeds, trees. Whatever is there. On a day with no wind, the surface is smooth. It reflects the sky, the clouds, the trees on the shore.

A breeze comes. The surface ripples and the reflections break. For a while you cannot see below.

A few yards down, the water is still. The wind does not reach there.

Now let your body be the lake. Whatever holds you up is the earth that holds the water. The breath moves the surface. A little coming in, a little going out.

Thoughts, noises and emotions are the wind. They stir the water on top.

Further down, in the middle of the body, there is a still place. You can rest there while the water moves above.

You do not need to calm the surface. Waves are part of the lake too.

The day goes by. The light changes color. A storm comes, and the water turns gray and choppy.

Then it passes. Calm returns, or almost. The depths were still the whole time.

Night comes. The moon shows in the water, trembles a little, then moves on.

When you notice you were thinking about something else, nothing went wrong. That is what minds do. Come back to the water.

If anything becomes too much, open your eyes or move. You can stop whenever you want. Keep going on your own. The surface moves, the depths stay still.

If you drifted off, come back. To the moving surface, to the still water below.

If the image fades, stay with the breath, rising and falling like water.

Now let the image of the lake go. Feel your body again and the places where it rests. Notice the sounds around you. Slowly move your fingers and your toes. If you are on your back, roll onto one side before you sit up. When you are ready, open your eyes. That is all. You can come back to this lake whenever you need it.

What it is

This is a meditation with an image. You picture a lake, its water, its shore, the sky reflected in it, and then you let your body become that lake. The breath and whatever passes through the mind are the wind that stirs the surface. Further down the water stays still, and attention can rest there while there are waves above.

The image carries the instruction: you do not need to calm the surface to find the depths. It is close to the mountain meditation, which also lets the weather pass, but the mountain leans on the steadiness of a seated posture, and the lake on something softer, which receives and moves. That is why it also works lying down.

Where it comes from

The best-known form is Jon Kabat-Zinn's, the creator of the mindfulness-based stress reduction program that began in 1979 at the University of Massachusetts. Kabat-Zinn published the lake meditation in his 1994 book Wherever You Go, There You Are, alongside the mountain meditation, and recorded both as guided meditations in an audio series made to go with that book.

Still water as an image of a calm mind shows up in many traditions, but this form, with the body as a lake and a surface that moves over still depths, is Kabat-Zinn's. The script on this page was written for this site: it follows the same idea in different words.

What people use it for

Many people use it when the mind is very busy and asking it to calm down does not work. The image changes the question: the water on top does not have to go smooth; it is enough to notice that underneath there is a part that does not churn.

Others prefer it to the mountain because they can do it lying down, at the end of the day or with a tired body. And some use it as a way of looking at a strong emotion without fighting it: they let it be a wave.

What studies say

No studies of the lake meditation on its own were found. It is part of the materials of mindfulness programs, and what has been studied are those programs as a whole.

A review by Goyal and colleagues, published in 2014 in JAMA Internal Medicine, pooled 47 trials with 3,515 participants. For mindfulness programs it found moderate evidence of small to moderate improvements in anxiety, depression and pain, and low evidence of improvement in stress and quality of life. It found no evidence that they were better than other active treatments, and no clear effects on attention or sleep.

The NCCIH, part of the U.S. National Institutes of Health, notes that much of the research on meditation has been preliminary or not scientifically rigorous. In other words: many people find it useful, the effect measured in programs is modest, and it does not replace treatment.

What you may notice

Some people see the lake in detail; others have only a vague sense of water. Both work. If no image comes at all, stay with the breath, rising and falling like water.

It is common not to find the still place, especially on restless days. You do not need to find it: it is enough to know the water below is there even if you cannot feel it. If you get sleepy, especially lying down, open your eyes a little.

Sometimes the storm on the lake lines up with something weighing on you, and the feeling grows. You can open your eyes, move or stop. That is not the practice failing.

Which length to choose

All three lengths say the same words; what grows is the silence. In ten minutes the voice is with you almost the whole time. In fifteen there are longer stretches to stay with the water. In twenty, after nightfall, there is a good while on your own.

To begin, try ten minutes sitting, during the day. If you like the image, try fifteen or twenty, and try it lying down too.

Common mistakes

  • Wanting the surface to stay smooth. Waves are part of the lake.
  • Forcing your way to the depths. Knowing they are there is enough.
  • Sinking into the image until you fall asleep. If it happens often, sit up or open your eyes a little.
  • Using the calm below to avoid feeling what is above. Both are there at once.
  • Starting over every time you drift. Pick up wherever the voice is.

Keep in mind

  • Lying on your back makes it easy to fall asleep. If you want to stay awake, do it sitting.
  • Imagery can bring up difficult feelings or memories. You can open your eyes, move or stop at any time.
  • If you live with trauma or strong emotional distress, talk to a mental health professional first.

Common questions

Who created the lake meditation?

The best-known form is Jon Kabat-Zinn's. He published it in *Wherever You Go, There You Are* in 1994 and recorded it as a guided meditation. The script on this page was written for this site and follows the same idea.

What is the difference between the lake and mountain meditations?

Both let what changes pass by. The mountain leans on a steady seated posture and the weather passing over it. The lake leans on water, moving on top and still below, and it also works well lying down.

What if I can't feel any still place?

Nothing special. It happens often, especially on restless days. Notice the moving surface and remember that there is still water below, even if you cannot feel it today.

Can I do it in bed?

Yes. Lying on your back works well, though sleep comes more easily. If you want to stay awake, keep your eyes half open or do it sitting.

Sources